Two perspectives of proxy reporting of health-related quality of life using the euroqol-5D: An investigation of agreement

Steven McPhail, Elaine Beller, Terry Haines

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

52 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Proxy-reporting has been proposed as an alternative to self-report of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) for patients with poor cognition. There are 2 possible perspectives from which to complete a proxy-report, answer as the patient would (proxy-patient) or from the proxy's own perspective (proxy-proxy). Most research has not differentiated between perspectives. Agreement between patient and proxy-reports from either perspective has not been investigated using the Euroqol-5D (EQ-5D) among elderly hospital patients undergoing rehabilitation.

Objectives: Identify agreement levels between proxy-patient and patient self-report as well as proxy-proxy and patient self-report of the EQ-5D and investigate interaction effects of timing (admission vs. discharge) and basic cognition (intact vs. not intact).

Research Design: Repeated measures. inter-rater agreement investigation of clinician proxy-report. and patient self-report incorporating; proxy-patient reports (perspective A) and proxy-proxy reports (perspective 131). Subjects: Geriatric rehabilitation patients (n = 272) and their proxies (treating physiotherapists n 29).

Measures: EQ-5D for FlRQoL. and Mini Mental State Examination for cognition.

Results: One hundred fifty (89%) proxy-patient and 130 (98%) proxy-proxy datasets were complete. 51 perspective A and 52 perspective B patients did not have basic cognition intact. Proxy-patient assessments had strong agreement with self-report at discharge across all cognition levels (kappa = 0.76-0.95). but at admission had stronger agreement among patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.70-0.86) than patients with lower cognition (kappa = 0.47-0.76). At admission and discharge proxy-proxy assessments generally had moderate agreement with self-report among patients with poor cognition on most domains with proxies (giving lower scores than patients (kappa = 0.23-0.81). this is in contrast to proxy-proxy assessments and patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.55-0.95).

Conclusions: Clinician (physiotherapist) proxy-reports among this Population generally had good agreement with patient self-report though this was affected by proxy perspective, patient cognition, and timing.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1140-1148
Number of pages9
JournalMedical Care
Volume46
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2008
Externally publishedYes

Cite this

@article{fa99c3603e894b279ebef56e87b7e6d0,
title = "Two perspectives of proxy reporting of health-related quality of life using the euroqol-5D: An investigation of agreement",
abstract = "Background: Proxy-reporting has been proposed as an alternative to self-report of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) for patients with poor cognition. There are 2 possible perspectives from which to complete a proxy-report, answer as the patient would (proxy-patient) or from the proxy's own perspective (proxy-proxy). Most research has not differentiated between perspectives. Agreement between patient and proxy-reports from either perspective has not been investigated using the Euroqol-5D (EQ-5D) among elderly hospital patients undergoing rehabilitation.Objectives: Identify agreement levels between proxy-patient and patient self-report as well as proxy-proxy and patient self-report of the EQ-5D and investigate interaction effects of timing (admission vs. discharge) and basic cognition (intact vs. not intact).Research Design: Repeated measures. inter-rater agreement investigation of clinician proxy-report. and patient self-report incorporating; proxy-patient reports (perspective A) and proxy-proxy reports (perspective 131). Subjects: Geriatric rehabilitation patients (n = 272) and their proxies (treating physiotherapists n 29).Measures: EQ-5D for FlRQoL. and Mini Mental State Examination for cognition.Results: One hundred fifty (89{\%}) proxy-patient and 130 (98{\%}) proxy-proxy datasets were complete. 51 perspective A and 52 perspective B patients did not have basic cognition intact. Proxy-patient assessments had strong agreement with self-report at discharge across all cognition levels (kappa = 0.76-0.95). but at admission had stronger agreement among patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.70-0.86) than patients with lower cognition (kappa = 0.47-0.76). At admission and discharge proxy-proxy assessments generally had moderate agreement with self-report among patients with poor cognition on most domains with proxies (giving lower scores than patients (kappa = 0.23-0.81). this is in contrast to proxy-proxy assessments and patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.55-0.95).Conclusions: Clinician (physiotherapist) proxy-reports among this Population generally had good agreement with patient self-report though this was affected by proxy perspective, patient cognition, and timing.",
author = "Steven McPhail and Elaine Beller and Terry Haines",
year = "2008",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1097/MLR.0b013e31817d69a6",
language = "English",
volume = "46",
pages = "1140--1148",
journal = "Medical Care",
issn = "0025-7079",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams & Wilkins",
number = "11",

}

Two perspectives of proxy reporting of health-related quality of life using the euroqol-5D : An investigation of agreement. / McPhail, Steven; Beller, Elaine; Haines, Terry.

In: Medical Care, Vol. 46, No. 11, 11.2008, p. 1140-1148.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Two perspectives of proxy reporting of health-related quality of life using the euroqol-5D

T2 - An investigation of agreement

AU - McPhail, Steven

AU - Beller, Elaine

AU - Haines, Terry

PY - 2008/11

Y1 - 2008/11

N2 - Background: Proxy-reporting has been proposed as an alternative to self-report of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) for patients with poor cognition. There are 2 possible perspectives from which to complete a proxy-report, answer as the patient would (proxy-patient) or from the proxy's own perspective (proxy-proxy). Most research has not differentiated between perspectives. Agreement between patient and proxy-reports from either perspective has not been investigated using the Euroqol-5D (EQ-5D) among elderly hospital patients undergoing rehabilitation.Objectives: Identify agreement levels between proxy-patient and patient self-report as well as proxy-proxy and patient self-report of the EQ-5D and investigate interaction effects of timing (admission vs. discharge) and basic cognition (intact vs. not intact).Research Design: Repeated measures. inter-rater agreement investigation of clinician proxy-report. and patient self-report incorporating; proxy-patient reports (perspective A) and proxy-proxy reports (perspective 131). Subjects: Geriatric rehabilitation patients (n = 272) and their proxies (treating physiotherapists n 29).Measures: EQ-5D for FlRQoL. and Mini Mental State Examination for cognition.Results: One hundred fifty (89%) proxy-patient and 130 (98%) proxy-proxy datasets were complete. 51 perspective A and 52 perspective B patients did not have basic cognition intact. Proxy-patient assessments had strong agreement with self-report at discharge across all cognition levels (kappa = 0.76-0.95). but at admission had stronger agreement among patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.70-0.86) than patients with lower cognition (kappa = 0.47-0.76). At admission and discharge proxy-proxy assessments generally had moderate agreement with self-report among patients with poor cognition on most domains with proxies (giving lower scores than patients (kappa = 0.23-0.81). this is in contrast to proxy-proxy assessments and patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.55-0.95).Conclusions: Clinician (physiotherapist) proxy-reports among this Population generally had good agreement with patient self-report though this was affected by proxy perspective, patient cognition, and timing.

AB - Background: Proxy-reporting has been proposed as an alternative to self-report of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) for patients with poor cognition. There are 2 possible perspectives from which to complete a proxy-report, answer as the patient would (proxy-patient) or from the proxy's own perspective (proxy-proxy). Most research has not differentiated between perspectives. Agreement between patient and proxy-reports from either perspective has not been investigated using the Euroqol-5D (EQ-5D) among elderly hospital patients undergoing rehabilitation.Objectives: Identify agreement levels between proxy-patient and patient self-report as well as proxy-proxy and patient self-report of the EQ-5D and investigate interaction effects of timing (admission vs. discharge) and basic cognition (intact vs. not intact).Research Design: Repeated measures. inter-rater agreement investigation of clinician proxy-report. and patient self-report incorporating; proxy-patient reports (perspective A) and proxy-proxy reports (perspective 131). Subjects: Geriatric rehabilitation patients (n = 272) and their proxies (treating physiotherapists n 29).Measures: EQ-5D for FlRQoL. and Mini Mental State Examination for cognition.Results: One hundred fifty (89%) proxy-patient and 130 (98%) proxy-proxy datasets were complete. 51 perspective A and 52 perspective B patients did not have basic cognition intact. Proxy-patient assessments had strong agreement with self-report at discharge across all cognition levels (kappa = 0.76-0.95). but at admission had stronger agreement among patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.70-0.86) than patients with lower cognition (kappa = 0.47-0.76). At admission and discharge proxy-proxy assessments generally had moderate agreement with self-report among patients with poor cognition on most domains with proxies (giving lower scores than patients (kappa = 0.23-0.81). this is in contrast to proxy-proxy assessments and patients with better cognition (kappa = 0.55-0.95).Conclusions: Clinician (physiotherapist) proxy-reports among this Population generally had good agreement with patient self-report though this was affected by proxy perspective, patient cognition, and timing.

U2 - 10.1097/MLR.0b013e31817d69a6

DO - 10.1097/MLR.0b013e31817d69a6

M3 - Article

VL - 46

SP - 1140

EP - 1148

JO - Medical Care

JF - Medical Care

SN - 0025-7079

IS - 11

ER -