Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime: A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia

Russell Smandych, RA Lincoln, Paul Wilson

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This article provides a theoretical starting point for the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime. The authors contend that any attempt to develop such a theory has to proceed on three fronts: (a) through offering a cross-cultural explanation of the problem of aboriginal overrepresentation; (b) through undertaking comparative research aimed at accounting for aboriginal offending patterns that often lie outside the official picture of overrepresentation; and (c) through developing a primarily societal-based (as opposed to individualist) cross-cultural theory of aboriginal criminality that is able to account for identified cross-national patterns of aboriginal overrepresentation and aboriginal offending. As a takeoff point for this series of interconnected and overlapping comparative research efforts, the authors undertake an examination of the state of research and theory about the causes of aboriginal overrepresentation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In order to explain the similar patterns of overrepresentation found among aboriginal peoples in Canada, Australia, and other countries, the authors identify and synthesize a number of different cross-cultural theories of crime recently developed by comparative criminologists that can be used in working toward the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationIssues in comparative criminology
EditorsP Beirne, D Nelken
Place of PublicationBrookfield
PublisherAshgate Publishing Limited
Pages99-122
Number of pages24
ISBN (Print)1855216019
Publication statusPublished - 1997

Fingerprint

cultural theory
justice
offense
Canada
comparative research
Criminality
examination
cause

Cite this

Smandych, R., Lincoln, RA., & Wilson, P. (1997). Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime: A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In P. Beirne, & D. Nelken (Eds.), Issues in comparative criminology (pp. 99-122). Brookfield: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Smandych, Russell ; Lincoln, RA ; Wilson, Paul. / Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime : A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. Issues in comparative criminology. editor / P Beirne ; D Nelken. Brookfield : Ashgate Publishing Limited, 1997. pp. 99-122
@inbook{bf6e5e9bfab84bcea35faa0229bfd004,
title = "Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime: A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia",
abstract = "This article provides a theoretical starting point for the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime. The authors contend that any attempt to develop such a theory has to proceed on three fronts: (a) through offering a cross-cultural explanation of the problem of aboriginal overrepresentation; (b) through undertaking comparative research aimed at accounting for aboriginal offending patterns that often lie outside the official picture of overrepresentation; and (c) through developing a primarily societal-based (as opposed to individualist) cross-cultural theory of aboriginal criminality that is able to account for identified cross-national patterns of aboriginal overrepresentation and aboriginal offending. As a takeoff point for this series of interconnected and overlapping comparative research efforts, the authors undertake an examination of the state of research and theory about the causes of aboriginal overrepresentation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In order to explain the similar patterns of overrepresentation found among aboriginal peoples in Canada, Australia, and other countries, the authors identify and synthesize a number of different cross-cultural theories of crime recently developed by comparative criminologists that can be used in working toward the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime.",
author = "Russell Smandych and RA Lincoln and Paul Wilson",
year = "1997",
language = "English",
isbn = "1855216019",
pages = "99--122",
editor = "P Beirne and D Nelken",
booktitle = "Issues in comparative criminology",
publisher = "Ashgate Publishing Limited",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Smandych, R, Lincoln, RA & Wilson, P 1997, Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime: A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. in P Beirne & D Nelken (eds), Issues in comparative criminology. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Brookfield, pp. 99-122.

Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime : A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. / Smandych, Russell; Lincoln, RA; Wilson, Paul.

Issues in comparative criminology. ed. / P Beirne; D Nelken. Brookfield : Ashgate Publishing Limited, 1997. p. 99-122.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime

T2 - A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia

AU - Smandych, Russell

AU - Lincoln, RA

AU - Wilson, Paul

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - This article provides a theoretical starting point for the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime. The authors contend that any attempt to develop such a theory has to proceed on three fronts: (a) through offering a cross-cultural explanation of the problem of aboriginal overrepresentation; (b) through undertaking comparative research aimed at accounting for aboriginal offending patterns that often lie outside the official picture of overrepresentation; and (c) through developing a primarily societal-based (as opposed to individualist) cross-cultural theory of aboriginal criminality that is able to account for identified cross-national patterns of aboriginal overrepresentation and aboriginal offending. As a takeoff point for this series of interconnected and overlapping comparative research efforts, the authors undertake an examination of the state of research and theory about the causes of aboriginal overrepresentation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In order to explain the similar patterns of overrepresentation found among aboriginal peoples in Canada, Australia, and other countries, the authors identify and synthesize a number of different cross-cultural theories of crime recently developed by comparative criminologists that can be used in working toward the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime.

AB - This article provides a theoretical starting point for the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime. The authors contend that any attempt to develop such a theory has to proceed on three fronts: (a) through offering a cross-cultural explanation of the problem of aboriginal overrepresentation; (b) through undertaking comparative research aimed at accounting for aboriginal offending patterns that often lie outside the official picture of overrepresentation; and (c) through developing a primarily societal-based (as opposed to individualist) cross-cultural theory of aboriginal criminality that is able to account for identified cross-national patterns of aboriginal overrepresentation and aboriginal offending. As a takeoff point for this series of interconnected and overlapping comparative research efforts, the authors undertake an examination of the state of research and theory about the causes of aboriginal overrepresentation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In order to explain the similar patterns of overrepresentation found among aboriginal peoples in Canada, Australia, and other countries, the authors identify and synthesize a number of different cross-cultural theories of crime recently developed by comparative criminologists that can be used in working toward the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime.

M3 - Chapter

SN - 1855216019

SP - 99

EP - 122

BT - Issues in comparative criminology

A2 - Beirne, P

A2 - Nelken, D

PB - Ashgate Publishing Limited

CY - Brookfield

ER -

Smandych R, Lincoln RA, Wilson P. Towards a cross-cultural theory of Aboriginal crime: A comparative study of the problem of over-representation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In Beirne P, Nelken D, editors, Issues in comparative criminology. Brookfield: Ashgate Publishing Limited. 1997. p. 99-122