Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)
2 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Leal regulation of transactions in the human body is in one sense a new phenomenon. Traditionally, in seeking to delineate between what is human and what is not, the common law has sought to exclude the human body from its conceptualisation of transactions as involving commodities. This approach theoretically avoids the potential for a human to become the very antithesis of personhood: namely property. From this perspective, bodily transactions that are now routine, including organ transplants, assisted reproduction and surrogacy, present a challenge for the law.

On the other hand, property itself is a construct of its time and the society in which it exists. The exclusion of humans and their bodies from regulatory frameworks had depended upon who is within the law and who is homo sacer (outside the law), and how social custom perceives the body from time to time. For example, at one end of a spectrum of bodily transactions, slavery was actively practised in England until the late eighteenth century. Slavery is now completely prohibited within an international human rights framework. Far more recently, the bodies of children and women have been under the control of the head of the household, the pater familias, and the paternalistic state.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationSurrogacy, law and human rights
EditorsPaula Gerber, Katie O'Byrne
Place of PublicationOxon, UK
PublisherAshgate Publishing Limited
Pages13-29
Number of pages17
ISBN (Electronic)9781472451255
ISBN (Print)9781472451248
Publication statusPublished - 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

human dignity
human rights
transaction
slavery
Law
organ transplant
common law
eighteenth century
commodity
exclusion
regulation
time

Cite this

Galloway, K. (2015). Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy. In P. Gerber, & K. O'Byrne (Eds.), Surrogacy, law and human rights (pp. 13-29). Oxon, UK: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Galloway, Kathrine. / Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy. Surrogacy, law and human rights. editor / Paula Gerber ; Katie O'Byrne. Oxon, UK : Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2015. pp. 13-29
@inbook{dfb4f43c525246afbea9fe1bef6cf7b5,
title = "Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy",
abstract = "Leal regulation of transactions in the human body is in one sense a new phenomenon. Traditionally, in seeking to delineate between what is human and what is not, the common law has sought to exclude the human body from its conceptualisation of transactions as involving commodities. This approach theoretically avoids the potential for a human to become the very antithesis of personhood: namely property. From this perspective, bodily transactions that are now routine, including organ transplants, assisted reproduction and surrogacy, present a challenge for the law. On the other hand, property itself is a construct of its time and the society in which it exists. The exclusion of humans and their bodies from regulatory frameworks had depended upon who is within the law and who is homo sacer (outside the law), and how social custom perceives the body from time to time. For example, at one end of a spectrum of bodily transactions, slavery was actively practised in England until the late eighteenth century. Slavery is now completely prohibited within an international human rights framework. Far more recently, the bodies of children and women have been under the control of the head of the household, the pater familias, and the paternalistic state.",
author = "Kathrine Galloway",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781472451248",
pages = "13--29",
editor = "Paula Gerber and Katie O'Byrne",
booktitle = "Surrogacy, law and human rights",
publisher = "Ashgate Publishing Limited",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Galloway, K 2015, Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy. in P Gerber & K O'Byrne (eds), Surrogacy, law and human rights. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Oxon, UK, pp. 13-29.

Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy. / Galloway, Kathrine.

Surrogacy, law and human rights. ed. / Paula Gerber; Katie O'Byrne. Oxon, UK : Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2015. p. 13-29.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy

AU - Galloway, Kathrine

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Leal regulation of transactions in the human body is in one sense a new phenomenon. Traditionally, in seeking to delineate between what is human and what is not, the common law has sought to exclude the human body from its conceptualisation of transactions as involving commodities. This approach theoretically avoids the potential for a human to become the very antithesis of personhood: namely property. From this perspective, bodily transactions that are now routine, including organ transplants, assisted reproduction and surrogacy, present a challenge for the law. On the other hand, property itself is a construct of its time and the society in which it exists. The exclusion of humans and their bodies from regulatory frameworks had depended upon who is within the law and who is homo sacer (outside the law), and how social custom perceives the body from time to time. For example, at one end of a spectrum of bodily transactions, slavery was actively practised in England until the late eighteenth century. Slavery is now completely prohibited within an international human rights framework. Far more recently, the bodies of children and women have been under the control of the head of the household, the pater familias, and the paternalistic state.

AB - Leal regulation of transactions in the human body is in one sense a new phenomenon. Traditionally, in seeking to delineate between what is human and what is not, the common law has sought to exclude the human body from its conceptualisation of transactions as involving commodities. This approach theoretically avoids the potential for a human to become the very antithesis of personhood: namely property. From this perspective, bodily transactions that are now routine, including organ transplants, assisted reproduction and surrogacy, present a challenge for the law. On the other hand, property itself is a construct of its time and the society in which it exists. The exclusion of humans and their bodies from regulatory frameworks had depended upon who is within the law and who is homo sacer (outside the law), and how social custom perceives the body from time to time. For example, at one end of a spectrum of bodily transactions, slavery was actively practised in England until the late eighteenth century. Slavery is now completely prohibited within an international human rights framework. Far more recently, the bodies of children and women have been under the control of the head of the household, the pater familias, and the paternalistic state.

UR - https://www.routledge.com/Surrogacy-Law-and-Human-Rights/Gerber-OByrne/p/book/9781472451248

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84949452017&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781472451248

SP - 13

EP - 29

BT - Surrogacy, law and human rights

A2 - Gerber, Paula

A2 - O'Byrne, Katie

PB - Ashgate Publishing Limited

CY - Oxon, UK

ER -

Galloway K. Theoretical approaches to human dignity, human rights and surrogacy. In Gerber P, O'Byrne K, editors, Surrogacy, law and human rights. Oxon, UK: Ashgate Publishing Limited. 2015. p. 13-29