The better-than-average effect in Hong Kong and the United States: The role of personal trait importance and cultural trait importance

Kim Pong Tam, Angela K y Leung, Young Hoon Kim, Chi Yue Chiu, Ivy Yee Man Lau, Al K C Au

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

People tend to make self-aggrandizing social comparisons on traits that are important to the self. However, existing research on the better-than-average effect (BTAE) and trait importance does not distinguish between personal trait importance (participants' ratings of the importance of certain traits to themselves) and cultural trait importance (participants' perceptions of the importance of the traits to the cultural group to which they belong). We demonstrated the utility of this distinction by examining the joint effects of personal importance and cultural importance on the BTAE among Hong Kong Chinese and American participants. Results showed that the BTAE was more pronounced for personally important traits among both Chinese and American participants. More important, the magnitude of the BTAE was smaller on culturally important traits among Chinese participants only. Chinese participants displayed the strongest BTAE on personally important and culturally unimportant traits, and the smallest BTAE on personally unimportant and culturally important ones. American participants showed the smallest BTAE on personally and culturally unimportant traits. These findings underscore the importance of distinguishing personal trait importance and cultural trait importance in understanding the cultural effects on self-aggrandizing social comparisons. They further suggest that in cultures where people are expected to be modest in self-expression (e.g., Chinese culture), people would avoid claiming superiority on highly culturally important traits even when these traits are important to the self.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)915-930
Number of pages16
JournalJournal of Cross-Cultural Psychology
Volume43
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Asian Americans
Hong Kong
Research
rating

Cite this

Tam, Kim Pong ; Leung, Angela K y ; Kim, Young Hoon ; Chiu, Chi Yue ; Lau, Ivy Yee Man ; Au, Al K C. / The better-than-average effect in Hong Kong and the United States : The role of personal trait importance and cultural trait importance. In: Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology. 2012 ; Vol. 43, No. 6. pp. 915-930.
@article{1bda4bf27ba1403ba1ae0df4f0c1e91b,
title = "The better-than-average effect in Hong Kong and the United States: The role of personal trait importance and cultural trait importance",
abstract = "People tend to make self-aggrandizing social comparisons on traits that are important to the self. However, existing research on the better-than-average effect (BTAE) and trait importance does not distinguish between personal trait importance (participants' ratings of the importance of certain traits to themselves) and cultural trait importance (participants' perceptions of the importance of the traits to the cultural group to which they belong). We demonstrated the utility of this distinction by examining the joint effects of personal importance and cultural importance on the BTAE among Hong Kong Chinese and American participants. Results showed that the BTAE was more pronounced for personally important traits among both Chinese and American participants. More important, the magnitude of the BTAE was smaller on culturally important traits among Chinese participants only. Chinese participants displayed the strongest BTAE on personally important and culturally unimportant traits, and the smallest BTAE on personally unimportant and culturally important ones. American participants showed the smallest BTAE on personally and culturally unimportant traits. These findings underscore the importance of distinguishing personal trait importance and cultural trait importance in understanding the cultural effects on self-aggrandizing social comparisons. They further suggest that in cultures where people are expected to be modest in self-expression (e.g., Chinese culture), people would avoid claiming superiority on highly culturally important traits even when these traits are important to the self.",
author = "Tam, {Kim Pong} and Leung, {Angela K y} and Kim, {Young Hoon} and Chiu, {Chi Yue} and Lau, {Ivy Yee Man} and Au, {Al K C}",
year = "2012",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1177/0022022112443774",
language = "English",
volume = "43",
pages = "915--930",
journal = "Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology",
issn = "0022-0221",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "6",

}

The better-than-average effect in Hong Kong and the United States : The role of personal trait importance and cultural trait importance. / Tam, Kim Pong; Leung, Angela K y; Kim, Young Hoon; Chiu, Chi Yue; Lau, Ivy Yee Man; Au, Al K C.

In: Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, Vol. 43, No. 6, 08.2012, p. 915-930.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The better-than-average effect in Hong Kong and the United States

T2 - The role of personal trait importance and cultural trait importance

AU - Tam, Kim Pong

AU - Leung, Angela K y

AU - Kim, Young Hoon

AU - Chiu, Chi Yue

AU - Lau, Ivy Yee Man

AU - Au, Al K C

PY - 2012/8

Y1 - 2012/8

N2 - People tend to make self-aggrandizing social comparisons on traits that are important to the self. However, existing research on the better-than-average effect (BTAE) and trait importance does not distinguish between personal trait importance (participants' ratings of the importance of certain traits to themselves) and cultural trait importance (participants' perceptions of the importance of the traits to the cultural group to which they belong). We demonstrated the utility of this distinction by examining the joint effects of personal importance and cultural importance on the BTAE among Hong Kong Chinese and American participants. Results showed that the BTAE was more pronounced for personally important traits among both Chinese and American participants. More important, the magnitude of the BTAE was smaller on culturally important traits among Chinese participants only. Chinese participants displayed the strongest BTAE on personally important and culturally unimportant traits, and the smallest BTAE on personally unimportant and culturally important ones. American participants showed the smallest BTAE on personally and culturally unimportant traits. These findings underscore the importance of distinguishing personal trait importance and cultural trait importance in understanding the cultural effects on self-aggrandizing social comparisons. They further suggest that in cultures where people are expected to be modest in self-expression (e.g., Chinese culture), people would avoid claiming superiority on highly culturally important traits even when these traits are important to the self.

AB - People tend to make self-aggrandizing social comparisons on traits that are important to the self. However, existing research on the better-than-average effect (BTAE) and trait importance does not distinguish between personal trait importance (participants' ratings of the importance of certain traits to themselves) and cultural trait importance (participants' perceptions of the importance of the traits to the cultural group to which they belong). We demonstrated the utility of this distinction by examining the joint effects of personal importance and cultural importance on the BTAE among Hong Kong Chinese and American participants. Results showed that the BTAE was more pronounced for personally important traits among both Chinese and American participants. More important, the magnitude of the BTAE was smaller on culturally important traits among Chinese participants only. Chinese participants displayed the strongest BTAE on personally important and culturally unimportant traits, and the smallest BTAE on personally unimportant and culturally important ones. American participants showed the smallest BTAE on personally and culturally unimportant traits. These findings underscore the importance of distinguishing personal trait importance and cultural trait importance in understanding the cultural effects on self-aggrandizing social comparisons. They further suggest that in cultures where people are expected to be modest in self-expression (e.g., Chinese culture), people would avoid claiming superiority on highly culturally important traits even when these traits are important to the self.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84863519843&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0022022112443774

DO - 10.1177/0022022112443774

M3 - Article

VL - 43

SP - 915

EP - 930

JO - Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology

JF - Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology

SN - 0022-0221

IS - 6

ER -