Service guarantees and consequential loss under the Australian Consumer Law: The illusion of uniformity

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

2 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The aim of the new Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is to 'create a single national consumer law' establishing a uniform set of rules across all jurisdictions in relation to consumer protection. There are, however, exceptions to this uniformity. Although the ACL is a national law, it comes into effect by the activation of separate jurisdiction of the Commonwealth and states and territories. The focus of this article is on one specific aspect of the ACL, namely, the consumer guarantees relating to the supply of services. Importantly, the ACL's uniformity is seriously undermined where there is a failure to comply with the guarantee that services are supplied with due care and skill, where such failure results in personal injury or property damage. Here, state and territory laws that determine liability for careless conduct and that establish relevant defences under the Civil Liability Acts continue to apply. Given that there are considerable differences between the jurisdictions, particularly in relation to the available defences, a uniform national approach therefore does not operate in this context.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)43-55
Number of pages13
JournalCompetition and Consumer Law
Volume20
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

guarantee
Law
jurisdiction
liability
consumer protection
activation
damages
act
supply

Cite this

@article{44f0513c76f0408ca5969526f5f9c186,
title = "Service guarantees and consequential loss under the Australian Consumer Law: The illusion of uniformity",
abstract = "The aim of the new Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is to 'create a single national consumer law' establishing a uniform set of rules across all jurisdictions in relation to consumer protection. There are, however, exceptions to this uniformity. Although the ACL is a national law, it comes into effect by the activation of separate jurisdiction of the Commonwealth and states and territories. The focus of this article is on one specific aspect of the ACL, namely, the consumer guarantees relating to the supply of services. Importantly, the ACL's uniformity is seriously undermined where there is a failure to comply with the guarantee that services are supplied with due care and skill, where such failure results in personal injury or property damage. Here, state and territory laws that determine liability for careless conduct and that establish relevant defences under the Civil Liability Acts continue to apply. Given that there are considerable differences between the jurisdictions, particularly in relation to the available defences, a uniform national approach therefore does not operate in this context.",
author = "Joachim Dietrich",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "43--55",
journal = "Competition and Consumer Law",
issn = "1039-5598",
publisher = "LexisNexis Butterworths",
number = "1",

}

Service guarantees and consequential loss under the Australian Consumer Law : The illusion of uniformity. / Dietrich, Joachim.

In: Competition and Consumer Law, Vol. 20, No. 1, 2012, p. 43-55.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Service guarantees and consequential loss under the Australian Consumer Law

T2 - The illusion of uniformity

AU - Dietrich, Joachim

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - The aim of the new Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is to 'create a single national consumer law' establishing a uniform set of rules across all jurisdictions in relation to consumer protection. There are, however, exceptions to this uniformity. Although the ACL is a national law, it comes into effect by the activation of separate jurisdiction of the Commonwealth and states and territories. The focus of this article is on one specific aspect of the ACL, namely, the consumer guarantees relating to the supply of services. Importantly, the ACL's uniformity is seriously undermined where there is a failure to comply with the guarantee that services are supplied with due care and skill, where such failure results in personal injury or property damage. Here, state and territory laws that determine liability for careless conduct and that establish relevant defences under the Civil Liability Acts continue to apply. Given that there are considerable differences between the jurisdictions, particularly in relation to the available defences, a uniform national approach therefore does not operate in this context.

AB - The aim of the new Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is to 'create a single national consumer law' establishing a uniform set of rules across all jurisdictions in relation to consumer protection. There are, however, exceptions to this uniformity. Although the ACL is a national law, it comes into effect by the activation of separate jurisdiction of the Commonwealth and states and territories. The focus of this article is on one specific aspect of the ACL, namely, the consumer guarantees relating to the supply of services. Importantly, the ACL's uniformity is seriously undermined where there is a failure to comply with the guarantee that services are supplied with due care and skill, where such failure results in personal injury or property damage. Here, state and territory laws that determine liability for careless conduct and that establish relevant defences under the Civil Liability Acts continue to apply. Given that there are considerable differences between the jurisdictions, particularly in relation to the available defences, a uniform national approach therefore does not operate in this context.

M3 - Article

VL - 20

SP - 43

EP - 55

JO - Competition and Consumer Law

JF - Competition and Consumer Law

SN - 1039-5598

IS - 1

ER -