Questions about the effects of interventions: Examples of appraisals from different health professions

Tammy C Hoffmann, John W Bennett, Malcolm Boyle, Jeff S. Coombes, Mark R. Elkins, Edzard Ernst, Angela Morgan, Lisa Nissen, Claire Rickard, Sharon L Sanders, Alan Spencer, Caroline Wright

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingOther chapter contributionResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This chapter is an accompaniment to the previous chapter (Chapter 4) in which you learnt how to critically appraise evidence about the effects of interventions. In order to further illustrate the key points from Chapter 4, this chapter contains a number of worked examples of questions about the effects of interventions. As we mentioned in the preface of the book, we believe that it can be easier to learn the process of critical appraisal when you see some worked examples of how it is done, and it is even better when the examples are from your own health profession. Therefore, this chapter (and likewise Chapters 7, 9 and 11) contains examples from a range of health professions. Some of the clinical examples are relevant to more than one health profession. Each example is formatted in a similar manner and contains the following elements;
- a clinical scenario that explains the origins of the clinical question
- the clinical question
- the search terms and databases used to find evidence to answer the clinical question - a brief description of the article chosen and the reason for its selection - a structured abstract of the chosen article 8 an appraisal of the risk of bias of the evidence - a summary of the main results of the article that are relevant to the clinical question - a brief discussion about how the evidence can be used to inform practice.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationEvidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions
EditorsTammy Hoffmann, Sally Bennett, Chris del Mar
Place of PublicationChatswood, Australia
PublisherElsevier
Pages97-135
Number of pages39
ISBN (Print)9780729541350
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Health
Scenarios
Evidence
Term
Range of data

Cite this

Hoffmann, T. C., Bennett, J. W., Boyle, M., Coombes, J. S., Elkins, M. R., Ernst, E., ... Wright, C. (2013). Questions about the effects of interventions: Examples of appraisals from different health professions. In T. Hoffmann, S. Bennett, & C. del Mar (Eds.), Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions (pp. 97-135). Chatswood, Australia : Elsevier.
Hoffmann, Tammy C ; Bennett, John W ; Boyle, Malcolm ; Coombes, Jeff S. ; Elkins, Mark R. ; Ernst, Edzard ; Morgan, Angela ; Nissen, Lisa ; Rickard, Claire ; Sanders, Sharon L ; Spencer, Alan ; Wright, Caroline. / Questions about the effects of interventions : Examples of appraisals from different health professions. Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions. editor / Tammy Hoffmann ; Sally Bennett ; Chris del Mar. Chatswood, Australia : Elsevier, 2013. pp. 97-135
@inbook{571ae3723a2b42eba5a3c3cb73b3d9b1,
title = "Questions about the effects of interventions: Examples of appraisals from different health professions",
abstract = "This chapter is an accompaniment to the previous chapter (Chapter 4) in which you learnt how to critically appraise evidence about the effects of interventions. In order to further illustrate the key points from Chapter 4, this chapter contains a number of worked examples of questions about the effects of interventions. As we mentioned in the preface of the book, we believe that it can be easier to learn the process of critical appraisal when you see some worked examples of how it is done, and it is even better when the examples are from your own health profession. Therefore, this chapter (and likewise Chapters 7, 9 and 11) contains examples from a range of health professions. Some of the clinical examples are relevant to more than one health profession. Each example is formatted in a similar manner and contains the following elements;- a clinical scenario that explains the origins of the clinical question- the clinical question - the search terms and databases used to find evidence to answer the clinical question - a brief description of the article chosen and the reason for its selection - a structured abstract of the chosen article 8 an appraisal of the risk of bias of the evidence - a summary of the main results of the article that are relevant to the clinical question - a brief discussion about how the evidence can be used to inform practice.",
author = "Hoffmann, {Tammy C} and Bennett, {John W} and Malcolm Boyle and Coombes, {Jeff S.} and Elkins, {Mark R.} and Edzard Ernst and Angela Morgan and Lisa Nissen and Claire Rickard and Sanders, {Sharon L} and Alan Spencer and Caroline Wright",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780729541350",
pages = "97--135",
editor = "Tammy Hoffmann and Sally Bennett and {del Mar}, Chris",
booktitle = "Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions",
publisher = "Elsevier",
address = "Netherlands",

}

Hoffmann, TC, Bennett, JW, Boyle, M, Coombes, JS, Elkins, MR, Ernst, E, Morgan, A, Nissen, L, Rickard, C, Sanders, SL, Spencer, A & Wright, C 2013, Questions about the effects of interventions: Examples of appraisals from different health professions. in T Hoffmann, S Bennett & C del Mar (eds), Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions. Elsevier, Chatswood, Australia , pp. 97-135.

Questions about the effects of interventions : Examples of appraisals from different health professions. / Hoffmann, Tammy C; Bennett, John W; Boyle, Malcolm; Coombes, Jeff S.; Elkins, Mark R.; Ernst, Edzard; Morgan, Angela; Nissen, Lisa; Rickard, Claire; Sanders, Sharon L; Spencer, Alan; Wright, Caroline.

Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions. ed. / Tammy Hoffmann; Sally Bennett; Chris del Mar. Chatswood, Australia : Elsevier, 2013. p. 97-135.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingOther chapter contributionResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Questions about the effects of interventions

T2 - Examples of appraisals from different health professions

AU - Hoffmann, Tammy C

AU - Bennett, John W

AU - Boyle, Malcolm

AU - Coombes, Jeff S.

AU - Elkins, Mark R.

AU - Ernst, Edzard

AU - Morgan, Angela

AU - Nissen, Lisa

AU - Rickard, Claire

AU - Sanders, Sharon L

AU - Spencer, Alan

AU - Wright, Caroline

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This chapter is an accompaniment to the previous chapter (Chapter 4) in which you learnt how to critically appraise evidence about the effects of interventions. In order to further illustrate the key points from Chapter 4, this chapter contains a number of worked examples of questions about the effects of interventions. As we mentioned in the preface of the book, we believe that it can be easier to learn the process of critical appraisal when you see some worked examples of how it is done, and it is even better when the examples are from your own health profession. Therefore, this chapter (and likewise Chapters 7, 9 and 11) contains examples from a range of health professions. Some of the clinical examples are relevant to more than one health profession. Each example is formatted in a similar manner and contains the following elements;- a clinical scenario that explains the origins of the clinical question- the clinical question - the search terms and databases used to find evidence to answer the clinical question - a brief description of the article chosen and the reason for its selection - a structured abstract of the chosen article 8 an appraisal of the risk of bias of the evidence - a summary of the main results of the article that are relevant to the clinical question - a brief discussion about how the evidence can be used to inform practice.

AB - This chapter is an accompaniment to the previous chapter (Chapter 4) in which you learnt how to critically appraise evidence about the effects of interventions. In order to further illustrate the key points from Chapter 4, this chapter contains a number of worked examples of questions about the effects of interventions. As we mentioned in the preface of the book, we believe that it can be easier to learn the process of critical appraisal when you see some worked examples of how it is done, and it is even better when the examples are from your own health profession. Therefore, this chapter (and likewise Chapters 7, 9 and 11) contains examples from a range of health professions. Some of the clinical examples are relevant to more than one health profession. Each example is formatted in a similar manner and contains the following elements;- a clinical scenario that explains the origins of the clinical question- the clinical question - the search terms and databases used to find evidence to answer the clinical question - a brief description of the article chosen and the reason for its selection - a structured abstract of the chosen article 8 an appraisal of the risk of bias of the evidence - a summary of the main results of the article that are relevant to the clinical question - a brief discussion about how the evidence can be used to inform practice.

UR - http://www.elsevierhealth.com.au/evidence-based-practice-across-the-health-professions-9780729541350.html

M3 - Other chapter contribution

SN - 9780729541350

SP - 97

EP - 135

BT - Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions

A2 - Hoffmann, Tammy

A2 - Bennett, Sally

A2 - del Mar, Chris

PB - Elsevier

CY - Chatswood, Australia

ER -

Hoffmann TC, Bennett JW, Boyle M, Coombes JS, Elkins MR, Ernst E et al. Questions about the effects of interventions: Examples of appraisals from different health professions. In Hoffmann T, Bennett S, del Mar C, editors, Evidence-Based Practice Across the Health Professions. Chatswood, Australia : Elsevier. 2013. p. 97-135