Quality and quantity of paediatric research: An analysis of the OTseeker database

Tammy Hoffmann, Kryss McKenna, Tahnya Hadi, Sally Bennett, Annie McCluskey, Leigh Tooth

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim: This study aimed to analyse the quantity and quality of paediatric research evidence contained in the OTseeker database and to compare the findings with surveys of paediatric occupational therapy practice.

Methods: In June 2005, systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials contained in OTseeker were analysed according to year of publication and the client diagnostic groups and interventions addressed. The internal validity scores of the trials were determined (according to the PEDro scale (partitioned)) and the outcome measures used extracted.

Results: Of 3294 papers contained in OTseeker, 372 (11.3%) were related to paediatrics. The mean internal validity score of the trials was 2.5/8. The five most frequently studied diagnostic groups were mental health/psychosocial issues, neurology, learning disabilities, developmental delay and 'other'. There was much variation in the outcome measures used, with a large number of outcome measures used in only one or a few studies. The five most frequently studied interventions were behavioural interventions, consumer education, psychosocial techniques, interventions for carers/parents and developmental therapy.

Conclusion: OTseeker contains a considerable amount of research relevant to paediatric occupational therapy practice. There was some congruence between the papers and practice surveys regarding client diagnostic groups and interventions, but little between the outcome measures used in research and those used in clinical practice.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)113-123
Number of pages11
JournalAustralian Occupational Therapy Journal
Volume54
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2007
Externally publishedYes

Cite this

Hoffmann, Tammy ; McKenna, Kryss ; Hadi, Tahnya ; Bennett, Sally ; McCluskey, Annie ; Tooth, Leigh. / Quality and quantity of paediatric research : An analysis of the OTseeker database. In: Australian Occupational Therapy Journal. 2007 ; Vol. 54, No. 2. pp. 113-123.
@article{07ce9664aaad465fb22f01e5be9c2da4,
title = "Quality and quantity of paediatric research: An analysis of the OTseeker database",
abstract = "Aim: This study aimed to analyse the quantity and quality of paediatric research evidence contained in the OTseeker database and to compare the findings with surveys of paediatric occupational therapy practice.Methods: In June 2005, systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials contained in OTseeker were analysed according to year of publication and the client diagnostic groups and interventions addressed. The internal validity scores of the trials were determined (according to the PEDro scale (partitioned)) and the outcome measures used extracted.Results: Of 3294 papers contained in OTseeker, 372 (11.3{\%}) were related to paediatrics. The mean internal validity score of the trials was 2.5/8. The five most frequently studied diagnostic groups were mental health/psychosocial issues, neurology, learning disabilities, developmental delay and 'other'. There was much variation in the outcome measures used, with a large number of outcome measures used in only one or a few studies. The five most frequently studied interventions were behavioural interventions, consumer education, psychosocial techniques, interventions for carers/parents and developmental therapy.Conclusion: OTseeker contains a considerable amount of research relevant to paediatric occupational therapy practice. There was some congruence between the papers and practice surveys regarding client diagnostic groups and interventions, but little between the outcome measures used in research and those used in clinical practice.",
author = "Tammy Hoffmann and Kryss McKenna and Tahnya Hadi and Sally Bennett and Annie McCluskey and Leigh Tooth",
year = "2007",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/j.1440-1630.2006.00588.x",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "113--123",
journal = "Australian Occupational Therapy Journal",
issn = "0045-0766",
publisher = "Wiley Online Library",
number = "2",

}

Quality and quantity of paediatric research : An analysis of the OTseeker database. / Hoffmann, Tammy; McKenna, Kryss; Hadi, Tahnya; Bennett, Sally; McCluskey, Annie; Tooth, Leigh.

In: Australian Occupational Therapy Journal, Vol. 54, No. 2, 06.2007, p. 113-123.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quality and quantity of paediatric research

T2 - An analysis of the OTseeker database

AU - Hoffmann, Tammy

AU - McKenna, Kryss

AU - Hadi, Tahnya

AU - Bennett, Sally

AU - McCluskey, Annie

AU - Tooth, Leigh

PY - 2007/6

Y1 - 2007/6

N2 - Aim: This study aimed to analyse the quantity and quality of paediatric research evidence contained in the OTseeker database and to compare the findings with surveys of paediatric occupational therapy practice.Methods: In June 2005, systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials contained in OTseeker were analysed according to year of publication and the client diagnostic groups and interventions addressed. The internal validity scores of the trials were determined (according to the PEDro scale (partitioned)) and the outcome measures used extracted.Results: Of 3294 papers contained in OTseeker, 372 (11.3%) were related to paediatrics. The mean internal validity score of the trials was 2.5/8. The five most frequently studied diagnostic groups were mental health/psychosocial issues, neurology, learning disabilities, developmental delay and 'other'. There was much variation in the outcome measures used, with a large number of outcome measures used in only one or a few studies. The five most frequently studied interventions were behavioural interventions, consumer education, psychosocial techniques, interventions for carers/parents and developmental therapy.Conclusion: OTseeker contains a considerable amount of research relevant to paediatric occupational therapy practice. There was some congruence between the papers and practice surveys regarding client diagnostic groups and interventions, but little between the outcome measures used in research and those used in clinical practice.

AB - Aim: This study aimed to analyse the quantity and quality of paediatric research evidence contained in the OTseeker database and to compare the findings with surveys of paediatric occupational therapy practice.Methods: In June 2005, systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials contained in OTseeker were analysed according to year of publication and the client diagnostic groups and interventions addressed. The internal validity scores of the trials were determined (according to the PEDro scale (partitioned)) and the outcome measures used extracted.Results: Of 3294 papers contained in OTseeker, 372 (11.3%) were related to paediatrics. The mean internal validity score of the trials was 2.5/8. The five most frequently studied diagnostic groups were mental health/psychosocial issues, neurology, learning disabilities, developmental delay and 'other'. There was much variation in the outcome measures used, with a large number of outcome measures used in only one or a few studies. The five most frequently studied interventions were behavioural interventions, consumer education, psychosocial techniques, interventions for carers/parents and developmental therapy.Conclusion: OTseeker contains a considerable amount of research relevant to paediatric occupational therapy practice. There was some congruence between the papers and practice surveys regarding client diagnostic groups and interventions, but little between the outcome measures used in research and those used in clinical practice.

U2 - 10.1111/j.1440-1630.2006.00588.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1440-1630.2006.00588.x

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 113

EP - 123

JO - Australian Occupational Therapy Journal

JF - Australian Occupational Therapy Journal

SN - 0045-0766

IS - 2

ER -