Positive affect is associated with reduced fixation in a realistic medical simulation

Monique F Crane, Sue Brouwers, Kirsty Forrest, Suyin Tan, Thomas Loveday, Mark W Wiggins, Chris Munday, Leila David

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: This study extends previous research by exploring the association between mood states (i.e., positive and negative affect) and fixation in practicing anesthetists using a realistic medical simulation.

BACKGROUND: The impact of practitioner emotional states on fixation is a neglected area of research. Emerging evidence is demonstrating the role of positive affect in facilitating problem solving and innovation, with demonstrated implications for practitioner fixation.

METHOD: Twelve practicing anesthetists (4 females; Mage= 39 years; SD = 6.71) were involved in a medical simulation. Prior to the simulation, practitioners rated the frequency they had experienced various positive and negative emotions in the previous three days. During the simulation, the patient deteriorated rapidly, and anesthetists were observed for their degree of fixation. After the simulation, practitioners indicated the frequency of these same emotions during the simulation.

RESULTS: Nonparametric correlations were used to explore the independent relationships between positive and negative affect and the behavioral measures. Only positive affect impacted the likelihood of fixation. Anesthetists who reported more frequent recent positive affect in the three days prior to the simulation and during the simulation tended to be less fixated as judged by independent raters, identified a decline in patient oxygen saturation more quickly, and more rapidly implemented the necessary intervention (surgical cricothyroidotomy).

CONCLUSION: These findings have some real-world implications for positive affect in patient safety.

APPLICATION: This research has broad implications for professions where fixation may impair practice. This research suggests that professional training should teach practitioners to identify their emotions and understand the role of these emotions in fixation.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)821-832
Number of pages12
JournalHuman Factors: the journal of the human factors and ergonomics society
Volume59
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Emotions
simulation
Research
emotion
Patient Safety
Innovation
Oxygen
Anesthetists
mood
profession
innovation
evidence

Cite this

Crane, Monique F ; Brouwers, Sue ; Forrest, Kirsty ; Tan, Suyin ; Loveday, Thomas ; Wiggins, Mark W ; Munday, Chris ; David, Leila. / Positive affect is associated with reduced fixation in a realistic medical simulation. In: Human Factors: the journal of the human factors and ergonomics society. 2017 ; Vol. 59, No. 5. pp. 821-832.
@article{4215cf506d0f412189deeae6f14b2dec,
title = "Positive affect is associated with reduced fixation in a realistic medical simulation",
abstract = "OBJECTIVE: This study extends previous research by exploring the association between mood states (i.e., positive and negative affect) and fixation in practicing anesthetists using a realistic medical simulation.BACKGROUND: The impact of practitioner emotional states on fixation is a neglected area of research. Emerging evidence is demonstrating the role of positive affect in facilitating problem solving and innovation, with demonstrated implications for practitioner fixation.METHOD: Twelve practicing anesthetists (4 females; Mage= 39 years; SD = 6.71) were involved in a medical simulation. Prior to the simulation, practitioners rated the frequency they had experienced various positive and negative emotions in the previous three days. During the simulation, the patient deteriorated rapidly, and anesthetists were observed for their degree of fixation. After the simulation, practitioners indicated the frequency of these same emotions during the simulation.RESULTS: Nonparametric correlations were used to explore the independent relationships between positive and negative affect and the behavioral measures. Only positive affect impacted the likelihood of fixation. Anesthetists who reported more frequent recent positive affect in the three days prior to the simulation and during the simulation tended to be less fixated as judged by independent raters, identified a decline in patient oxygen saturation more quickly, and more rapidly implemented the necessary intervention (surgical cricothyroidotomy).CONCLUSION: These findings have some real-world implications for positive affect in patient safety.APPLICATION: This research has broad implications for professions where fixation may impair practice. This research suggests that professional training should teach practitioners to identify their emotions and understand the role of these emotions in fixation.",
author = "Crane, {Monique F} and Sue Brouwers and Kirsty Forrest and Suyin Tan and Thomas Loveday and Wiggins, {Mark W} and Chris Munday and Leila David",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1177/0018720817695191",
language = "English",
volume = "59",
pages = "821--832",
journal = "Human Factors",
issn = "0018-7208",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "5",

}

Positive affect is associated with reduced fixation in a realistic medical simulation. / Crane, Monique F; Brouwers, Sue; Forrest, Kirsty; Tan, Suyin; Loveday, Thomas; Wiggins, Mark W; Munday, Chris; David, Leila.

In: Human Factors: the journal of the human factors and ergonomics society, Vol. 59, No. 5, 08.2017, p. 821-832.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Positive affect is associated with reduced fixation in a realistic medical simulation

AU - Crane, Monique F

AU - Brouwers, Sue

AU - Forrest, Kirsty

AU - Tan, Suyin

AU - Loveday, Thomas

AU - Wiggins, Mark W

AU - Munday, Chris

AU - David, Leila

PY - 2017/8

Y1 - 2017/8

N2 - OBJECTIVE: This study extends previous research by exploring the association between mood states (i.e., positive and negative affect) and fixation in practicing anesthetists using a realistic medical simulation.BACKGROUND: The impact of practitioner emotional states on fixation is a neglected area of research. Emerging evidence is demonstrating the role of positive affect in facilitating problem solving and innovation, with demonstrated implications for practitioner fixation.METHOD: Twelve practicing anesthetists (4 females; Mage= 39 years; SD = 6.71) were involved in a medical simulation. Prior to the simulation, practitioners rated the frequency they had experienced various positive and negative emotions in the previous three days. During the simulation, the patient deteriorated rapidly, and anesthetists were observed for their degree of fixation. After the simulation, practitioners indicated the frequency of these same emotions during the simulation.RESULTS: Nonparametric correlations were used to explore the independent relationships between positive and negative affect and the behavioral measures. Only positive affect impacted the likelihood of fixation. Anesthetists who reported more frequent recent positive affect in the three days prior to the simulation and during the simulation tended to be less fixated as judged by independent raters, identified a decline in patient oxygen saturation more quickly, and more rapidly implemented the necessary intervention (surgical cricothyroidotomy).CONCLUSION: These findings have some real-world implications for positive affect in patient safety.APPLICATION: This research has broad implications for professions where fixation may impair practice. This research suggests that professional training should teach practitioners to identify their emotions and understand the role of these emotions in fixation.

AB - OBJECTIVE: This study extends previous research by exploring the association between mood states (i.e., positive and negative affect) and fixation in practicing anesthetists using a realistic medical simulation.BACKGROUND: The impact of practitioner emotional states on fixation is a neglected area of research. Emerging evidence is demonstrating the role of positive affect in facilitating problem solving and innovation, with demonstrated implications for practitioner fixation.METHOD: Twelve practicing anesthetists (4 females; Mage= 39 years; SD = 6.71) were involved in a medical simulation. Prior to the simulation, practitioners rated the frequency they had experienced various positive and negative emotions in the previous three days. During the simulation, the patient deteriorated rapidly, and anesthetists were observed for their degree of fixation. After the simulation, practitioners indicated the frequency of these same emotions during the simulation.RESULTS: Nonparametric correlations were used to explore the independent relationships between positive and negative affect and the behavioral measures. Only positive affect impacted the likelihood of fixation. Anesthetists who reported more frequent recent positive affect in the three days prior to the simulation and during the simulation tended to be less fixated as judged by independent raters, identified a decline in patient oxygen saturation more quickly, and more rapidly implemented the necessary intervention (surgical cricothyroidotomy).CONCLUSION: These findings have some real-world implications for positive affect in patient safety.APPLICATION: This research has broad implications for professions where fixation may impair practice. This research suggests that professional training should teach practitioners to identify their emotions and understand the role of these emotions in fixation.

U2 - 10.1177/0018720817695191

DO - 10.1177/0018720817695191

M3 - Article

VL - 59

SP - 821

EP - 832

JO - Human Factors

JF - Human Factors

SN - 0018-7208

IS - 5

ER -