Obesity as a barrier to kidney transplantation: Time to eliminate the body weight bias?

Helen L MacLaughlin, Katrina L Campbell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleProfessionalpeer-review

Abstract

There is clear evidence that survival rates following transplantation far exceed those for remaining on dialysis, regardless of body size measured by body mass index (BMI). Studies over the past 15 years also suggest little to no difference in long-term outcomes, including graft survival and mortality, irrespective of BMI, in contrast to earlier evidence. However, weight bias still exists, as access to kidney transplantation remains inequitable in centers using arbitrary BMI limits. Clinicians faced with the decision regarding listing based on body size are not helped by conflicting recommendations in national and international guidelines. Therefore, in clinical practice, obesity, and recommendations for weight loss, remain a controversial issue when assessing suitability for kidney transplantation. Obesity management interventions in end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), whether for weight loss for transplantation listing or for slowing kidney disease progression, are under-explored in trial settings. Bariatric surgery is the most successful treatment for obesity, but carries increased risk in the ESKD population, and the desired outcome of kidney transplant listing is not guaranteed. Centers that limit transplants to those meeting arbitrary levels of body mass, rather than adopting an individualized assessment approach, may be unfairly depriving many ESKD patients of the survival and quality of life benefits derived from kidney transplantation. However, robotic kidney transplantation surgery holds promise for reducing perioperative risks related to obesity, and may therefore represent an opportunity to remove listing criteria based on size.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)219-222
Number of pages4
JournalSeminars in Dialysis
Volume32
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 2 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

Kidney Transplantation
Obesity
Body Weight
Chronic Kidney Failure
Body Mass Index
Body Size
Weight Loss
Transplantation
Transplants
Bariatric Surgery
Kidney Diseases
Robotics
Graft Survival
Disease Progression
Dialysis
Survival Rate
Quality of Life
Guidelines
Kidney
Weights and Measures

Cite this

@article{58bdfaa5cc894bec8a6400896519794c,
title = "Obesity as a barrier to kidney transplantation: Time to eliminate the body weight bias?",
abstract = "There is clear evidence that survival rates following transplantation far exceed those for remaining on dialysis, regardless of body size measured by body mass index (BMI). Studies over the past 15 years also suggest little to no difference in long-term outcomes, including graft survival and mortality, irrespective of BMI, in contrast to earlier evidence. However, weight bias still exists, as access to kidney transplantation remains inequitable in centers using arbitrary BMI limits. Clinicians faced with the decision regarding listing based on body size are not helped by conflicting recommendations in national and international guidelines. Therefore, in clinical practice, obesity, and recommendations for weight loss, remain a controversial issue when assessing suitability for kidney transplantation. Obesity management interventions in end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), whether for weight loss for transplantation listing or for slowing kidney disease progression, are under-explored in trial settings. Bariatric surgery is the most successful treatment for obesity, but carries increased risk in the ESKD population, and the desired outcome of kidney transplant listing is not guaranteed. Centers that limit transplants to those meeting arbitrary levels of body mass, rather than adopting an individualized assessment approach, may be unfairly depriving many ESKD patients of the survival and quality of life benefits derived from kidney transplantation. However, robotic kidney transplantation surgery holds promise for reducing perioperative risks related to obesity, and may therefore represent an opportunity to remove listing criteria based on size.",
author = "MacLaughlin, {Helen L} and Campbell, {Katrina L}",
note = "{\circledC} 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1111/sdi.12783",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "219--222",
journal = "Seminars in Dialysis",
issn = "0894-0959",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

Obesity as a barrier to kidney transplantation : Time to eliminate the body weight bias? / MacLaughlin, Helen L; Campbell, Katrina L.

In: Seminars in Dialysis, Vol. 32, No. 3, 02.04.2019, p. 219-222.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleProfessionalpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Obesity as a barrier to kidney transplantation

T2 - Time to eliminate the body weight bias?

AU - MacLaughlin, Helen L

AU - Campbell, Katrina L

N1 - © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

PY - 2019/4/2

Y1 - 2019/4/2

N2 - There is clear evidence that survival rates following transplantation far exceed those for remaining on dialysis, regardless of body size measured by body mass index (BMI). Studies over the past 15 years also suggest little to no difference in long-term outcomes, including graft survival and mortality, irrespective of BMI, in contrast to earlier evidence. However, weight bias still exists, as access to kidney transplantation remains inequitable in centers using arbitrary BMI limits. Clinicians faced with the decision regarding listing based on body size are not helped by conflicting recommendations in national and international guidelines. Therefore, in clinical practice, obesity, and recommendations for weight loss, remain a controversial issue when assessing suitability for kidney transplantation. Obesity management interventions in end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), whether for weight loss for transplantation listing or for slowing kidney disease progression, are under-explored in trial settings. Bariatric surgery is the most successful treatment for obesity, but carries increased risk in the ESKD population, and the desired outcome of kidney transplant listing is not guaranteed. Centers that limit transplants to those meeting arbitrary levels of body mass, rather than adopting an individualized assessment approach, may be unfairly depriving many ESKD patients of the survival and quality of life benefits derived from kidney transplantation. However, robotic kidney transplantation surgery holds promise for reducing perioperative risks related to obesity, and may therefore represent an opportunity to remove listing criteria based on size.

AB - There is clear evidence that survival rates following transplantation far exceed those for remaining on dialysis, regardless of body size measured by body mass index (BMI). Studies over the past 15 years also suggest little to no difference in long-term outcomes, including graft survival and mortality, irrespective of BMI, in contrast to earlier evidence. However, weight bias still exists, as access to kidney transplantation remains inequitable in centers using arbitrary BMI limits. Clinicians faced with the decision regarding listing based on body size are not helped by conflicting recommendations in national and international guidelines. Therefore, in clinical practice, obesity, and recommendations for weight loss, remain a controversial issue when assessing suitability for kidney transplantation. Obesity management interventions in end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), whether for weight loss for transplantation listing or for slowing kidney disease progression, are under-explored in trial settings. Bariatric surgery is the most successful treatment for obesity, but carries increased risk in the ESKD population, and the desired outcome of kidney transplant listing is not guaranteed. Centers that limit transplants to those meeting arbitrary levels of body mass, rather than adopting an individualized assessment approach, may be unfairly depriving many ESKD patients of the survival and quality of life benefits derived from kidney transplantation. However, robotic kidney transplantation surgery holds promise for reducing perioperative risks related to obesity, and may therefore represent an opportunity to remove listing criteria based on size.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063790882&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/sdi.12783

DO - 10.1111/sdi.12783

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 219

EP - 222

JO - Seminars in Dialysis

JF - Seminars in Dialysis

SN - 0894-0959

IS - 3

ER -