Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter

Michelle McLean, Salma Al Ahbabi, Mouza Al Ameri, Muneera Al Mansoori, Fatima Al Yahyaei, Roos Bernsen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

CONTEXT: Increasingly, male medical students report being refused by female patients, particularly in obstetrics and gynaecology, which is impacting on recruitment into the discipline. However, little has been documented in terms of Muslim patients and medical students in the clinical consultation.

METHODS: Female Emirati nationals (n = 218) attending out-patient clinics at a public hospital in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates (UAE), were interviewed by medical students. Participants were provided with four hypothetical clinical scenarios (three personal, one concerning a pre-pubertal child) and asked whether they would allow male and female students to be present at a consultation, take a history or perform an examination. They were also canvassed about their past experiences with medical students and their social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors.

RESULTS: Significant differences were recorded in terms of female versus male student involvement for all activities (P < 0.05-0.0005). For gynaecological and abdominal problems, patients would generally refuse male students. More than 50% of interviewees would not allow a male student to examine their face. Students of either gender could, however, examine their 8-year-old child. Although 47% of the women had had previous clinical encounters with students, in only 58% of consultations had the attending doctor asked their permission. Despite this, the women had generally felt comfortable, although satisfaction decreased with increasing age (P = 0.088). Almost 90% of the women believed that Emiratis had a social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors, but this decreased with increasing income (P = 0.004).

CONCLUSIONS: As many medical students will encounter Muslim patients during their training, they need to be sensitive to religious and cultural issues, particularly for personal examinations. In contexts where most patients are Muslim, alternative options (e.g. manikins, international rotations) may be required for male students. In the UAE, patient education may improve history-taking opportunities but will probably not transcend religious and cultural beliefs without intervention from religious leaders.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)306-15
Number of pages10
JournalMedical Education
Volume44
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2010
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

medical student
Muslim
United Arab Emirates
student
social responsibility
gynecology
examination
obstetrics
history
female student
leader
scenario
income
gender
education
experience

Cite this

McLean, M., Al Ahbabi, S., Al Ameri, M., Al Mansoori, M., Al Yahyaei, F., & Bernsen, R. (2010). Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter. Medical Education, 44(3), 306-15. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x
McLean, Michelle ; Al Ahbabi, Salma ; Al Ameri, Mouza ; Al Mansoori, Muneera ; Al Yahyaei, Fatima ; Bernsen, Roos. / Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter. In: Medical Education. 2010 ; Vol. 44, No. 3. pp. 306-15.
@article{b116a15b64ce44ffab9cf343c6262d26,
title = "Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter",
abstract = "CONTEXT: Increasingly, male medical students report being refused by female patients, particularly in obstetrics and gynaecology, which is impacting on recruitment into the discipline. However, little has been documented in terms of Muslim patients and medical students in the clinical consultation.METHODS: Female Emirati nationals (n = 218) attending out-patient clinics at a public hospital in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates (UAE), were interviewed by medical students. Participants were provided with four hypothetical clinical scenarios (three personal, one concerning a pre-pubertal child) and asked whether they would allow male and female students to be present at a consultation, take a history or perform an examination. They were also canvassed about their past experiences with medical students and their social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors.RESULTS: Significant differences were recorded in terms of female versus male student involvement for all activities (P < 0.05-0.0005). For gynaecological and abdominal problems, patients would generally refuse male students. More than 50{\%} of interviewees would not allow a male student to examine their face. Students of either gender could, however, examine their 8-year-old child. Although 47{\%} of the women had had previous clinical encounters with students, in only 58{\%} of consultations had the attending doctor asked their permission. Despite this, the women had generally felt comfortable, although satisfaction decreased with increasing age (P = 0.088). Almost 90{\%} of the women believed that Emiratis had a social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors, but this decreased with increasing income (P = 0.004).CONCLUSIONS: As many medical students will encounter Muslim patients during their training, they need to be sensitive to religious and cultural issues, particularly for personal examinations. In contexts where most patients are Muslim, alternative options (e.g. manikins, international rotations) may be required for male students. In the UAE, patient education may improve history-taking opportunities but will probably not transcend religious and cultural beliefs without intervention from religious leaders.",
author = "Michelle McLean and {Al Ahbabi}, Salma and {Al Ameri}, Mouza and {Al Mansoori}, Muneera and {Al Yahyaei}, Fatima and Roos Bernsen",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x",
language = "English",
volume = "44",
pages = "306--15",
journal = "British journal of medical education",
issn = "0308-0110",
publisher = "Wiley Blackwell (American Society Bone & Mineral Research)",
number = "3",

}

McLean, M, Al Ahbabi, S, Al Ameri, M, Al Mansoori, M, Al Yahyaei, F & Bernsen, R 2010, 'Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter' Medical Education, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 306-15. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x

Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter. / McLean, Michelle; Al Ahbabi, Salma; Al Ameri, Mouza; Al Mansoori, Muneera; Al Yahyaei, Fatima; Bernsen, Roos.

In: Medical Education, Vol. 44, No. 3, 03.2010, p. 306-15.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter

AU - McLean, Michelle

AU - Al Ahbabi, Salma

AU - Al Ameri, Mouza

AU - Al Mansoori, Muneera

AU - Al Yahyaei, Fatima

AU - Bernsen, Roos

PY - 2010/3

Y1 - 2010/3

N2 - CONTEXT: Increasingly, male medical students report being refused by female patients, particularly in obstetrics and gynaecology, which is impacting on recruitment into the discipline. However, little has been documented in terms of Muslim patients and medical students in the clinical consultation.METHODS: Female Emirati nationals (n = 218) attending out-patient clinics at a public hospital in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates (UAE), were interviewed by medical students. Participants were provided with four hypothetical clinical scenarios (three personal, one concerning a pre-pubertal child) and asked whether they would allow male and female students to be present at a consultation, take a history or perform an examination. They were also canvassed about their past experiences with medical students and their social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors.RESULTS: Significant differences were recorded in terms of female versus male student involvement for all activities (P < 0.05-0.0005). For gynaecological and abdominal problems, patients would generally refuse male students. More than 50% of interviewees would not allow a male student to examine their face. Students of either gender could, however, examine their 8-year-old child. Although 47% of the women had had previous clinical encounters with students, in only 58% of consultations had the attending doctor asked their permission. Despite this, the women had generally felt comfortable, although satisfaction decreased with increasing age (P = 0.088). Almost 90% of the women believed that Emiratis had a social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors, but this decreased with increasing income (P = 0.004).CONCLUSIONS: As many medical students will encounter Muslim patients during their training, they need to be sensitive to religious and cultural issues, particularly for personal examinations. In contexts where most patients are Muslim, alternative options (e.g. manikins, international rotations) may be required for male students. In the UAE, patient education may improve history-taking opportunities but will probably not transcend religious and cultural beliefs without intervention from religious leaders.

AB - CONTEXT: Increasingly, male medical students report being refused by female patients, particularly in obstetrics and gynaecology, which is impacting on recruitment into the discipline. However, little has been documented in terms of Muslim patients and medical students in the clinical consultation.METHODS: Female Emirati nationals (n = 218) attending out-patient clinics at a public hospital in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates (UAE), were interviewed by medical students. Participants were provided with four hypothetical clinical scenarios (three personal, one concerning a pre-pubertal child) and asked whether they would allow male and female students to be present at a consultation, take a history or perform an examination. They were also canvassed about their past experiences with medical students and their social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors.RESULTS: Significant differences were recorded in terms of female versus male student involvement for all activities (P < 0.05-0.0005). For gynaecological and abdominal problems, patients would generally refuse male students. More than 50% of interviewees would not allow a male student to examine their face. Students of either gender could, however, examine their 8-year-old child. Although 47% of the women had had previous clinical encounters with students, in only 58% of consultations had the attending doctor asked their permission. Despite this, the women had generally felt comfortable, although satisfaction decreased with increasing age (P = 0.088). Almost 90% of the women believed that Emiratis had a social responsibility to contribute towards the training of Emirati doctors, but this decreased with increasing income (P = 0.004).CONCLUSIONS: As many medical students will encounter Muslim patients during their training, they need to be sensitive to religious and cultural issues, particularly for personal examinations. In contexts where most patients are Muslim, alternative options (e.g. manikins, international rotations) may be required for male students. In the UAE, patient education may improve history-taking opportunities but will probably not transcend religious and cultural beliefs without intervention from religious leaders.

U2 - 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x

M3 - Article

VL - 44

SP - 306

EP - 315

JO - British journal of medical education

JF - British journal of medical education

SN - 0308-0110

IS - 3

ER -

McLean M, Al Ahbabi S, Al Ameri M, Al Mansoori M, Al Yahyaei F, Bernsen R. Muslim women and medical students in the clinical encounter. Medical Education. 2010 Mar;44(3):306-15. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03599.x