Moving beyond is identity: Concepts and discourses

Dirk S. Hovorka

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The ongoing debate about the identity of the Information Systems (IS) discipline is examined from a new perspective. Two recent studies are contrasted to demonstrate the limits of retrospective analysis for defining the field of IS. A new model for IS research, based on concepts and discourses is suggested. Latent Semantic Analysis is proposed as an approach to identifying concepts which form transdisciplinary discourses. Conceptual mapping across disciplines may elucidate fruitful areas of research and a transdisciplinary approach to research may improve research salience and intellectual contributions. Such an approach may also weaken or dissolve the discipline as an applied business/organizational field focused on the information technology artifact. This has the long term effect of maintaining intellectual plasticity and relevance, while expanding the range of intellectual contributions available to IS researchers. Moving beyond IS identity will require rethinking institutional structures upon which the identity of IS is currently dependent.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationICIS 2010 Proceedings
Subtitle of host publicationThirty First International Conference on Information Systems
Publication statusPublished - 2010
Event31st International Conference on Information Systems, ICIS 2010 - Saint Louis, MO, United States
Duration: 12 Dec 201015 Dec 2010
Conference number: 31st

Conference

Conference31st International Conference on Information Systems, ICIS 2010
Abbreviated titleICIS 2010
CountryUnited States
CitySaint Louis, MO
Period12/12/1015/12/10

Fingerprint

Information systems
Information technology
Plasticity
Semantics
Industry

Cite this

Hovorka, D. S. (2010). Moving beyond is identity: Concepts and discourses. In ICIS 2010 Proceedings: Thirty First International Conference on Information Systems
Hovorka, Dirk S. / Moving beyond is identity : Concepts and discourses. ICIS 2010 Proceedings: Thirty First International Conference on Information Systems. 2010.
@inproceedings{31dce7ee61fd48c7852469eb4b137c8f,
title = "Moving beyond is identity: Concepts and discourses",
abstract = "The ongoing debate about the identity of the Information Systems (IS) discipline is examined from a new perspective. Two recent studies are contrasted to demonstrate the limits of retrospective analysis for defining the field of IS. A new model for IS research, based on concepts and discourses is suggested. Latent Semantic Analysis is proposed as an approach to identifying concepts which form transdisciplinary discourses. Conceptual mapping across disciplines may elucidate fruitful areas of research and a transdisciplinary approach to research may improve research salience and intellectual contributions. Such an approach may also weaken or dissolve the discipline as an applied business/organizational field focused on the information technology artifact. This has the long term effect of maintaining intellectual plasticity and relevance, while expanding the range of intellectual contributions available to IS researchers. Moving beyond IS identity will require rethinking institutional structures upon which the identity of IS is currently dependent.",
author = "Hovorka, {Dirk S.}",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780615418988",
booktitle = "ICIS 2010 Proceedings",

}

Hovorka, DS 2010, Moving beyond is identity: Concepts and discourses. in ICIS 2010 Proceedings: Thirty First International Conference on Information Systems. 31st International Conference on Information Systems, ICIS 2010, Saint Louis, MO, United States, 12/12/10.

Moving beyond is identity : Concepts and discourses. / Hovorka, Dirk S.

ICIS 2010 Proceedings: Thirty First International Conference on Information Systems. 2010.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Moving beyond is identity

T2 - Concepts and discourses

AU - Hovorka, Dirk S.

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - The ongoing debate about the identity of the Information Systems (IS) discipline is examined from a new perspective. Two recent studies are contrasted to demonstrate the limits of retrospective analysis for defining the field of IS. A new model for IS research, based on concepts and discourses is suggested. Latent Semantic Analysis is proposed as an approach to identifying concepts which form transdisciplinary discourses. Conceptual mapping across disciplines may elucidate fruitful areas of research and a transdisciplinary approach to research may improve research salience and intellectual contributions. Such an approach may also weaken or dissolve the discipline as an applied business/organizational field focused on the information technology artifact. This has the long term effect of maintaining intellectual plasticity and relevance, while expanding the range of intellectual contributions available to IS researchers. Moving beyond IS identity will require rethinking institutional structures upon which the identity of IS is currently dependent.

AB - The ongoing debate about the identity of the Information Systems (IS) discipline is examined from a new perspective. Two recent studies are contrasted to demonstrate the limits of retrospective analysis for defining the field of IS. A new model for IS research, based on concepts and discourses is suggested. Latent Semantic Analysis is proposed as an approach to identifying concepts which form transdisciplinary discourses. Conceptual mapping across disciplines may elucidate fruitful areas of research and a transdisciplinary approach to research may improve research salience and intellectual contributions. Such an approach may also weaken or dissolve the discipline as an applied business/organizational field focused on the information technology artifact. This has the long term effect of maintaining intellectual plasticity and relevance, while expanding the range of intellectual contributions available to IS researchers. Moving beyond IS identity will require rethinking institutional structures upon which the identity of IS is currently dependent.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84870965745&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 9780615418988

BT - ICIS 2010 Proceedings

ER -

Hovorka DS. Moving beyond is identity: Concepts and discourses. In ICIS 2010 Proceedings: Thirty First International Conference on Information Systems. 2010