Internal audit quality: Insights from Audit Committee members, senior management and internal auditors

Andrew Trotman, Keith Duncan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

We investigate the concept of internal audit function (IAF) quality from a multi-stakeholder perspective through conducting 36 interviews with key IAF stakeholder groups: audit committee members, senior management, internal audit executives, and outsourced internal audit partners from the major accounting firms. We adapt established quality frameworks which suggest quality is a five-dimensional construct (including input, process, output, outcome, and contextual dimensions) to the internal audit context. We find that the various stakeholder groups focus on different quality dimensions in their evaluation of IAF quality. For example, the groups focus on the process dimension (internal audit executives), output dimension (audit committee members and internal audit partners), or outcome dimension (senior management and internal audit partners). We also find that the five dimensions comprise multiple indicators of IAF quality. We conduct six supplementary interviews with external audit partners to compare their insights on IAF quality to the focal IAF stakeholder groups. External auditors evaluate quality via the output dimension after an ex-ante assessment focusing on the input dimension. Finally, we contribute to the IAF quality literature by developing a multi-stakeholder IAF quality framework.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)235-259
Number of pages25
JournalAuditing: a Journal of Practice and Theory
Volume37
Issue number4
Early online date2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2018

Fingerprint

Audit committee
Internal audit
Auditors
Audit quality
Senior management
Internal audit function
Stakeholders
Focus groups
External auditor
Accounting firms
External audit
Auditor quality
Evaluation

Cite this

@article{eef9e4719d2e4cf8af5f39bcd992d7cc,
title = "Internal audit quality: Insights from Audit Committee members, senior management and internal auditors",
abstract = "We investigate the concept of internal audit function (IAF) quality from a multi-stakeholder perspective through conducting 36 interviews with key IAF stakeholder groups: audit committee members, senior management, internal audit executives, and outsourced internal audit partners from the major accounting firms. We adapt established quality frameworks which suggest quality is a five-dimensional construct (including input, process, output, outcome, and contextual dimensions) to the internal audit context. We find that the various stakeholder groups focus on different quality dimensions in their evaluation of IAF quality. For example, the groups focus on the process dimension (internal audit executives), output dimension (audit committee members and internal audit partners), or outcome dimension (senior management and internal audit partners). We also find that the five dimensions comprise multiple indicators of IAF quality. We conduct six supplementary interviews with external audit partners to compare their insights on IAF quality to the focal IAF stakeholder groups. External auditors evaluate quality via the output dimension after an ex-ante assessment focusing on the input dimension. Finally, we contribute to the IAF quality literature by developing a multi-stakeholder IAF quality framework.",
author = "Andrew Trotman and Keith Duncan",
year = "2018",
month = "11",
doi = "10.2308/ajpt-51877",
language = "English",
volume = "37",
pages = "235--259",
journal = "Auditing",
issn = "0278-0380",
publisher = "American Accounting Association",
number = "4",

}

Internal audit quality : Insights from Audit Committee members, senior management and internal auditors. / Trotman, Andrew; Duncan, Keith.

In: Auditing: a Journal of Practice and Theory, Vol. 37, No. 4, 11.2018, p. 235-259.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Internal audit quality

T2 - Insights from Audit Committee members, senior management and internal auditors

AU - Trotman, Andrew

AU - Duncan, Keith

PY - 2018/11

Y1 - 2018/11

N2 - We investigate the concept of internal audit function (IAF) quality from a multi-stakeholder perspective through conducting 36 interviews with key IAF stakeholder groups: audit committee members, senior management, internal audit executives, and outsourced internal audit partners from the major accounting firms. We adapt established quality frameworks which suggest quality is a five-dimensional construct (including input, process, output, outcome, and contextual dimensions) to the internal audit context. We find that the various stakeholder groups focus on different quality dimensions in their evaluation of IAF quality. For example, the groups focus on the process dimension (internal audit executives), output dimension (audit committee members and internal audit partners), or outcome dimension (senior management and internal audit partners). We also find that the five dimensions comprise multiple indicators of IAF quality. We conduct six supplementary interviews with external audit partners to compare their insights on IAF quality to the focal IAF stakeholder groups. External auditors evaluate quality via the output dimension after an ex-ante assessment focusing on the input dimension. Finally, we contribute to the IAF quality literature by developing a multi-stakeholder IAF quality framework.

AB - We investigate the concept of internal audit function (IAF) quality from a multi-stakeholder perspective through conducting 36 interviews with key IAF stakeholder groups: audit committee members, senior management, internal audit executives, and outsourced internal audit partners from the major accounting firms. We adapt established quality frameworks which suggest quality is a five-dimensional construct (including input, process, output, outcome, and contextual dimensions) to the internal audit context. We find that the various stakeholder groups focus on different quality dimensions in their evaluation of IAF quality. For example, the groups focus on the process dimension (internal audit executives), output dimension (audit committee members and internal audit partners), or outcome dimension (senior management and internal audit partners). We also find that the five dimensions comprise multiple indicators of IAF quality. We conduct six supplementary interviews with external audit partners to compare their insights on IAF quality to the focal IAF stakeholder groups. External auditors evaluate quality via the output dimension after an ex-ante assessment focusing on the input dimension. Finally, we contribute to the IAF quality literature by developing a multi-stakeholder IAF quality framework.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064871241&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2308/ajpt-51877

DO - 10.2308/ajpt-51877

M3 - Article

VL - 37

SP - 235

EP - 259

JO - Auditing

JF - Auditing

SN - 0278-0380

IS - 4

ER -