Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice

Suzanne Gough, Leah Greene, Anne Natali, Ralph MacKinnon, Stuart Roberts, Mark Hellaby, Andrew Whitcombe, Brian Webster-Henderson, Neil Tuttle, Debra Nestel

Research output: Contribution to journalMeeting AbstractResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Relevance: Simulated Patients (SPs) are volunteers, actors, service users or students trained to portray the role of patients or relatives in healthcare education [1]. Despite their involvement in healthcare education programmes, no standardised, evidence-based approach to training SPs in how to portray roles [2] or deliver constructive feedback as part of the debrief [1,3] existed in the UK. Furthermore, there was no framework to support organisations to plan and implement SP involvement in education, research and practice in the UK [3]. Purpose: The purpose of these projects was to develop, pilot and evaluate a standardised, evidence-based training programme for SP Trainers and SPs in the North West of England. The aims were to develop:
• A bespoke Simulated Patient Train-The-Trainer blended learning package (SP3T) for Simulation Trainers • An innovative Train-The-Simulated Patient (2TSP) blended learning package incorporating performing arts pedagogy for SPs • A framework, checklist and instructional guide for organisations, to enable them to implement and embed the SP Programme within their workplace • Guidance for ‘Trained SPs’ to volunteer in simulation based education (SBE) activities, via the ‘SP Passport’ and ‘Trained SP’ database
Approach/evaluation: Firstly, the literature was explored, then a regional survey was undertaken. Eighty nine participants responded from 24 different organisations across 4 Universities and 20 Hospital Trusts in the North West of England. Findings from the literature review and survey were used to develop the ‘Simulated Patient Programme’ and related resources. The programme incorporates the SP3T and 2TSP blended learning packages. Each package consists of pre-requisite e-learning, followed by an interactive workshop. The SP Programme [3,5], SP Common Framework [4], Instructional Guide [5], SP Database [5] and SP Passport [5] were developed and then piloted and evaluated by 18 SP Trainers and 34 SPs. Outcomes: • The survey identified variances in SP terminology, recruitment, payment, contracts, risk assessment and training, which were considered when developing the SP Programme and SP Common Framework. Training methods varied; over 1/3 of respondents were unsure of whether their organisation offered SP training. Challenges relating to recruitment and quality assurance of SP involvement were identified. • A standardised, evidence-based SP Programme incorporating innovative techniques has been produced. Resources enabled organizations the ability to plan, develop, integrate, deliver and evaluate SP involvement. • Valuable involvement of service users, who advised on the design and delivery of the SP Programme, plus a robust evaluation, has enabled the development of high quality, appropriate resources. • The Instructional Guide firmly embeds the SP Common Framework and SP Checklist; enabling organizations to successfully prepare for SP engagement. • SP Database testing confirmed usability in organisations with diverse IT infrastructures. • The SP Passport was reported to be a valuable resource to track, record and monitor SP training and involvement in SBE. Discussion and conclusions: The SP Programme is currently being rolled out throughout the North West of England, to ensure as many people as possible benefit from the project and resources. Impact and implications: It is envisaged that engagement with well-trained SPs will enhance SBE, improve education for the future and existing health and social care workforce and ultimately lead to improvements in patient safety.

Funding acknowledgement: The Simulated Patient Project was funded by NHS Health Education North West (NHS HENW).
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)e225-e226
Number of pages2
JournalPhysiotherapy
Volume102
Issue numberSuppl 1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2016
Externally publishedYes
EventEuropean Region World Confederation of Physical Therapists - AAC Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom
Duration: 11 Nov 201612 Nov 2016
Conference number: 4th
http://www.liverpool2016.com/programme/themes
http://www.liverpool2016.com/programme
http://www.liverpool2016.com/node/8

Fingerprint

Patient Simulation
Education
Research
Patient Participation
Organizations
England

Cite this

Gough, Suzanne ; Greene, Leah ; Natali, Anne ; MacKinnon, Ralph ; Roberts, Stuart ; Hellaby, Mark ; Whitcombe, Andrew ; Webster-Henderson, Brian ; Tuttle, Neil ; Nestel, Debra. / Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice. In: Physiotherapy. 2016 ; Vol. 102, No. Suppl 1. pp. e225-e226.
@article{c6b6b01b9b794092b8479b0e3cc7c79b,
title = "Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice",
abstract = "Relevance: Simulated Patients (SPs) are volunteers, actors, service users or students trained to portray the role of patients or relatives in healthcare education [1]. Despite their involvement in healthcare education programmes, no standardised, evidence-based approach to training SPs in how to portray roles [2] or deliver constructive feedback as part of the debrief [1,3] existed in the UK. Furthermore, there was no framework to support organisations to plan and implement SP involvement in education, research and practice in the UK [3]. Purpose: The purpose of these projects was to develop, pilot and evaluate a standardised, evidence-based training programme for SP Trainers and SPs in the North West of England. The aims were to develop:• A bespoke Simulated Patient Train-The-Trainer blended learning package (SP3T) for Simulation Trainers • An innovative Train-The-Simulated Patient (2TSP) blended learning package incorporating performing arts pedagogy for SPs • A framework, checklist and instructional guide for organisations, to enable them to implement and embed the SP Programme within their workplace • Guidance for ‘Trained SPs’ to volunteer in simulation based education (SBE) activities, via the ‘SP Passport’ and ‘Trained SP’ databaseApproach/evaluation: Firstly, the literature was explored, then a regional survey was undertaken. Eighty nine participants responded from 24 different organisations across 4 Universities and 20 Hospital Trusts in the North West of England. Findings from the literature review and survey were used to develop the ‘Simulated Patient Programme’ and related resources. The programme incorporates the SP3T and 2TSP blended learning packages. Each package consists of pre-requisite e-learning, followed by an interactive workshop. The SP Programme [3,5], SP Common Framework [4], Instructional Guide [5], SP Database [5] and SP Passport [5] were developed and then piloted and evaluated by 18 SP Trainers and 34 SPs. Outcomes: • The survey identified variances in SP terminology, recruitment, payment, contracts, risk assessment and training, which were considered when developing the SP Programme and SP Common Framework. Training methods varied; over 1/3 of respondents were unsure of whether their organisation offered SP training. Challenges relating to recruitment and quality assurance of SP involvement were identified. • A standardised, evidence-based SP Programme incorporating innovative techniques has been produced. Resources enabled organizations the ability to plan, develop, integrate, deliver and evaluate SP involvement. • Valuable involvement of service users, who advised on the design and delivery of the SP Programme, plus a robust evaluation, has enabled the development of high quality, appropriate resources. • The Instructional Guide firmly embeds the SP Common Framework and SP Checklist; enabling organizations to successfully prepare for SP engagement. • SP Database testing confirmed usability in organisations with diverse IT infrastructures. • The SP Passport was reported to be a valuable resource to track, record and monitor SP training and involvement in SBE. Discussion and conclusions: The SP Programme is currently being rolled out throughout the North West of England, to ensure as many people as possible benefit from the project and resources. Impact and implications: It is envisaged that engagement with well-trained SPs will enhance SBE, improve education for the future and existing health and social care workforce and ultimately lead to improvements in patient safety. Funding acknowledgement: The Simulated Patient Project was funded by NHS Health Education North West (NHS HENW).",
author = "Suzanne Gough and Leah Greene and Anne Natali and Ralph MacKinnon and Stuart Roberts and Mark Hellaby and Andrew Whitcombe and Brian Webster-Henderson and Neil Tuttle and Debra Nestel",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.physio.2016.10.278",
language = "English",
volume = "102",
pages = "e225--e226",
journal = "Physiotherapy",
issn = "0031-9406",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "Suppl 1",

}

Gough, S, Greene, L, Natali, A, MacKinnon, R, Roberts, S, Hellaby, M, Whitcombe, A, Webster-Henderson, B, Tuttle, N & Nestel, D 2016, 'Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice' Physiotherapy, vol. 102, no. Suppl 1, pp. e225-e226. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physio.2016.10.278

Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice. / Gough, Suzanne; Greene, Leah; Natali, Anne; MacKinnon, Ralph; Roberts, Stuart; Hellaby, Mark; Whitcombe, Andrew; Webster-Henderson, Brian; Tuttle, Neil; Nestel, Debra.

In: Physiotherapy, Vol. 102, No. Suppl 1, 01.11.2016, p. e225-e226.

Research output: Contribution to journalMeeting AbstractResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Increasing the quality and value of involving simulated patients in simulation-based education, research and practice

AU - Gough, Suzanne

AU - Greene, Leah

AU - Natali, Anne

AU - MacKinnon, Ralph

AU - Roberts, Stuart

AU - Hellaby, Mark

AU - Whitcombe, Andrew

AU - Webster-Henderson, Brian

AU - Tuttle, Neil

AU - Nestel, Debra

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - Relevance: Simulated Patients (SPs) are volunteers, actors, service users or students trained to portray the role of patients or relatives in healthcare education [1]. Despite their involvement in healthcare education programmes, no standardised, evidence-based approach to training SPs in how to portray roles [2] or deliver constructive feedback as part of the debrief [1,3] existed in the UK. Furthermore, there was no framework to support organisations to plan and implement SP involvement in education, research and practice in the UK [3]. Purpose: The purpose of these projects was to develop, pilot and evaluate a standardised, evidence-based training programme for SP Trainers and SPs in the North West of England. The aims were to develop:• A bespoke Simulated Patient Train-The-Trainer blended learning package (SP3T) for Simulation Trainers • An innovative Train-The-Simulated Patient (2TSP) blended learning package incorporating performing arts pedagogy for SPs • A framework, checklist and instructional guide for organisations, to enable them to implement and embed the SP Programme within their workplace • Guidance for ‘Trained SPs’ to volunteer in simulation based education (SBE) activities, via the ‘SP Passport’ and ‘Trained SP’ databaseApproach/evaluation: Firstly, the literature was explored, then a regional survey was undertaken. Eighty nine participants responded from 24 different organisations across 4 Universities and 20 Hospital Trusts in the North West of England. Findings from the literature review and survey were used to develop the ‘Simulated Patient Programme’ and related resources. The programme incorporates the SP3T and 2TSP blended learning packages. Each package consists of pre-requisite e-learning, followed by an interactive workshop. The SP Programme [3,5], SP Common Framework [4], Instructional Guide [5], SP Database [5] and SP Passport [5] were developed and then piloted and evaluated by 18 SP Trainers and 34 SPs. Outcomes: • The survey identified variances in SP terminology, recruitment, payment, contracts, risk assessment and training, which were considered when developing the SP Programme and SP Common Framework. Training methods varied; over 1/3 of respondents were unsure of whether their organisation offered SP training. Challenges relating to recruitment and quality assurance of SP involvement were identified. • A standardised, evidence-based SP Programme incorporating innovative techniques has been produced. Resources enabled organizations the ability to plan, develop, integrate, deliver and evaluate SP involvement. • Valuable involvement of service users, who advised on the design and delivery of the SP Programme, plus a robust evaluation, has enabled the development of high quality, appropriate resources. • The Instructional Guide firmly embeds the SP Common Framework and SP Checklist; enabling organizations to successfully prepare for SP engagement. • SP Database testing confirmed usability in organisations with diverse IT infrastructures. • The SP Passport was reported to be a valuable resource to track, record and monitor SP training and involvement in SBE. Discussion and conclusions: The SP Programme is currently being rolled out throughout the North West of England, to ensure as many people as possible benefit from the project and resources. Impact and implications: It is envisaged that engagement with well-trained SPs will enhance SBE, improve education for the future and existing health and social care workforce and ultimately lead to improvements in patient safety. Funding acknowledgement: The Simulated Patient Project was funded by NHS Health Education North West (NHS HENW).

AB - Relevance: Simulated Patients (SPs) are volunteers, actors, service users or students trained to portray the role of patients or relatives in healthcare education [1]. Despite their involvement in healthcare education programmes, no standardised, evidence-based approach to training SPs in how to portray roles [2] or deliver constructive feedback as part of the debrief [1,3] existed in the UK. Furthermore, there was no framework to support organisations to plan and implement SP involvement in education, research and practice in the UK [3]. Purpose: The purpose of these projects was to develop, pilot and evaluate a standardised, evidence-based training programme for SP Trainers and SPs in the North West of England. The aims were to develop:• A bespoke Simulated Patient Train-The-Trainer blended learning package (SP3T) for Simulation Trainers • An innovative Train-The-Simulated Patient (2TSP) blended learning package incorporating performing arts pedagogy for SPs • A framework, checklist and instructional guide for organisations, to enable them to implement and embed the SP Programme within their workplace • Guidance for ‘Trained SPs’ to volunteer in simulation based education (SBE) activities, via the ‘SP Passport’ and ‘Trained SP’ databaseApproach/evaluation: Firstly, the literature was explored, then a regional survey was undertaken. Eighty nine participants responded from 24 different organisations across 4 Universities and 20 Hospital Trusts in the North West of England. Findings from the literature review and survey were used to develop the ‘Simulated Patient Programme’ and related resources. The programme incorporates the SP3T and 2TSP blended learning packages. Each package consists of pre-requisite e-learning, followed by an interactive workshop. The SP Programme [3,5], SP Common Framework [4], Instructional Guide [5], SP Database [5] and SP Passport [5] were developed and then piloted and evaluated by 18 SP Trainers and 34 SPs. Outcomes: • The survey identified variances in SP terminology, recruitment, payment, contracts, risk assessment and training, which were considered when developing the SP Programme and SP Common Framework. Training methods varied; over 1/3 of respondents were unsure of whether their organisation offered SP training. Challenges relating to recruitment and quality assurance of SP involvement were identified. • A standardised, evidence-based SP Programme incorporating innovative techniques has been produced. Resources enabled organizations the ability to plan, develop, integrate, deliver and evaluate SP involvement. • Valuable involvement of service users, who advised on the design and delivery of the SP Programme, plus a robust evaluation, has enabled the development of high quality, appropriate resources. • The Instructional Guide firmly embeds the SP Common Framework and SP Checklist; enabling organizations to successfully prepare for SP engagement. • SP Database testing confirmed usability in organisations with diverse IT infrastructures. • The SP Passport was reported to be a valuable resource to track, record and monitor SP training and involvement in SBE. Discussion and conclusions: The SP Programme is currently being rolled out throughout the North West of England, to ensure as many people as possible benefit from the project and resources. Impact and implications: It is envisaged that engagement with well-trained SPs will enhance SBE, improve education for the future and existing health and social care workforce and ultimately lead to improvements in patient safety. Funding acknowledgement: The Simulated Patient Project was funded by NHS Health Education North West (NHS HENW).

U2 - 10.1016/j.physio.2016.10.278

DO - 10.1016/j.physio.2016.10.278

M3 - Meeting Abstract

VL - 102

SP - e225-e226

JO - Physiotherapy

JF - Physiotherapy

SN - 0031-9406

IS - Suppl 1

ER -