Increasing the demand for childhood vaccination in developing countries: a systematic review

Beverley J. Shea, Neil Andersson, David A Henry

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Background
Attempts to maintain or increase vaccination coverage almost all focus on supply side interventions: improving availability and delivery of vaccines. The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of efforts to increase demand is uncertain.

Methods
We performed a systematic review of studies that provided quantitative estimates of the impact of demand side interventions on uptake of routine childhood vaccination. We retrieved studies published up to Sept 2008.

Results
The initial search retrieved 468 potentially eligible studies, including four systematic reviews and eight original studies of the impact of interventions to increase demand for vaccination. We identified only two randomised controlled trials. Interventions with an impact on vaccination uptake included knowledge translation (KT) (mass media, village resource rooms and community discussions) and non-KT initiatives (incentives, economic empowerment, household visits by extension workers). Most claimed to increase vaccine coverage by 20 to 30%. Estimates of the cost per vaccinated child varied considerably with several in the range of $10-20 per vaccinated child.

Conclusion
Most studies reviewed here represented a low level of evidence. Mass media campaigns may be effective, but the impact depends on access to media and may be costly if run at a local level. The persistence of positive effects has not been investigated. The economics of demand side interventions have not been adequately assessed, but available data suggest that some may be very cost-effective.
Original languageEnglish
Article numberS5
JournalBMC International Health and Human Rights
Volume9
Issue numberSuppl 1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 14 Oct 2009
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Developing Countries
Vaccination
Mass Media
Vaccines
Economics
Costs and Cost Analysis
Translational Medical Research
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Motivation
Randomized Controlled Trials

Cite this

@article{927be32edeb1459c9dec62b5b3f1c8ab,
title = "Increasing the demand for childhood vaccination in developing countries: a systematic review",
abstract = "BackgroundAttempts to maintain or increase vaccination coverage almost all focus on supply side interventions: improving availability and delivery of vaccines. The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of efforts to increase demand is uncertain.MethodsWe performed a systematic review of studies that provided quantitative estimates of the impact of demand side interventions on uptake of routine childhood vaccination. We retrieved studies published up to Sept 2008.ResultsThe initial search retrieved 468 potentially eligible studies, including four systematic reviews and eight original studies of the impact of interventions to increase demand for vaccination. We identified only two randomised controlled trials. Interventions with an impact on vaccination uptake included knowledge translation (KT) (mass media, village resource rooms and community discussions) and non-KT initiatives (incentives, economic empowerment, household visits by extension workers). Most claimed to increase vaccine coverage by 20 to 30{\%}. Estimates of the cost per vaccinated child varied considerably with several in the range of $10-20 per vaccinated child.ConclusionMost studies reviewed here represented a low level of evidence. Mass media campaigns may be effective, but the impact depends on access to media and may be costly if run at a local level. The persistence of positive effects has not been investigated. The economics of demand side interventions have not been adequately assessed, but available data suggest that some may be very cost-effective.",
author = "Shea, {Beverley J.} and Neil Andersson and Henry, {David A}",
year = "2009",
month = "10",
day = "14",
doi = "10.1186/1472-698X-9-S1-S5",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
journal = "BMC International Health and Human Rights",
issn = "1472-698X",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "Suppl 1",

}

Increasing the demand for childhood vaccination in developing countries: a systematic review. / Shea, Beverley J.; Andersson, Neil; Henry, David A.

In: BMC International Health and Human Rights, Vol. 9, No. Suppl 1, S5, 14.10.2009.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Increasing the demand for childhood vaccination in developing countries: a systematic review

AU - Shea, Beverley J.

AU - Andersson, Neil

AU - Henry, David A

PY - 2009/10/14

Y1 - 2009/10/14

N2 - BackgroundAttempts to maintain or increase vaccination coverage almost all focus on supply side interventions: improving availability and delivery of vaccines. The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of efforts to increase demand is uncertain.MethodsWe performed a systematic review of studies that provided quantitative estimates of the impact of demand side interventions on uptake of routine childhood vaccination. We retrieved studies published up to Sept 2008.ResultsThe initial search retrieved 468 potentially eligible studies, including four systematic reviews and eight original studies of the impact of interventions to increase demand for vaccination. We identified only two randomised controlled trials. Interventions with an impact on vaccination uptake included knowledge translation (KT) (mass media, village resource rooms and community discussions) and non-KT initiatives (incentives, economic empowerment, household visits by extension workers). Most claimed to increase vaccine coverage by 20 to 30%. Estimates of the cost per vaccinated child varied considerably with several in the range of $10-20 per vaccinated child.ConclusionMost studies reviewed here represented a low level of evidence. Mass media campaigns may be effective, but the impact depends on access to media and may be costly if run at a local level. The persistence of positive effects has not been investigated. The economics of demand side interventions have not been adequately assessed, but available data suggest that some may be very cost-effective.

AB - BackgroundAttempts to maintain or increase vaccination coverage almost all focus on supply side interventions: improving availability and delivery of vaccines. The effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of efforts to increase demand is uncertain.MethodsWe performed a systematic review of studies that provided quantitative estimates of the impact of demand side interventions on uptake of routine childhood vaccination. We retrieved studies published up to Sept 2008.ResultsThe initial search retrieved 468 potentially eligible studies, including four systematic reviews and eight original studies of the impact of interventions to increase demand for vaccination. We identified only two randomised controlled trials. Interventions with an impact on vaccination uptake included knowledge translation (KT) (mass media, village resource rooms and community discussions) and non-KT initiatives (incentives, economic empowerment, household visits by extension workers). Most claimed to increase vaccine coverage by 20 to 30%. Estimates of the cost per vaccinated child varied considerably with several in the range of $10-20 per vaccinated child.ConclusionMost studies reviewed here represented a low level of evidence. Mass media campaigns may be effective, but the impact depends on access to media and may be costly if run at a local level. The persistence of positive effects has not been investigated. The economics of demand side interventions have not been adequately assessed, but available data suggest that some may be very cost-effective.

U2 - 10.1186/1472-698X-9-S1-S5

DO - 10.1186/1472-698X-9-S1-S5

M3 - Article

VL - 9

JO - BMC International Health and Human Rights

JF - BMC International Health and Human Rights

SN - 1472-698X

IS - Suppl 1

M1 - S5

ER -