Improving the relational aspects of trauma care through translational simulation

Victoria Brazil, Eve Purdy, Charlotte Alexander, Jack Matulich

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

18 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: Major trauma care is complex and requires individuals and teams to perform together in time critical, high-stakes situations. Scenario-based simulation is well established as a strategy for trauma teamwork improvement, but its role in the relational and cultural aspects of trauma care is less well understood. Relational coordination theory offers a framework through which we aimed to understand the impact of an established trauma simulation programme.

Methods: We studied simulation activities using a narrative survey of trauma providers from anaesthesia, emergency medicine, medical imaging, surgery, trauma service, intensive care, and pre-hospital providers at Gold Coast University Hospital, in conjunction with data from an ethnography. Data analysis was performed using a recursive approach-a simultaneous deductive approach using the relational coordination framework and an inductive analysis.

Results: Ninety-five of 480 (19.8%) staff completed free-text survey questions on simulation. Deductive analysis of data from these narrative survey results using the RC framework domains identified examples of shared goals, shared knowledge, communication and mutual respect. Two major themes from the inductive analysis-"Behaviour, process and system change" and "Culture and relationships"-aligned closely with findings from the RC analysis, with additional themes of "Personal and team learning" and the "Impact of the simulation experience" identified.

Conclusions: Our findings suggest that an established trauma simulation programme can have a profound impact on the relational aspects of care and the development of a collaborative culture, with perceived tangible impacts on teamwork behaviours and institutional systems and processes. The RC framework-shared knowledge, shared goals and mutual respect in the context of communication that is timely, accurate, frequent and problem-solving based-can provide a common language for simulation educators to design and debrief simulation exercises that aim to have a translational impact.

Original languageEnglish
Article number10
Number of pages10
JournalAdvances in Simulation (London, England)
Volume4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 21 May 2019

Fingerprint

Wounds and Injuries
Communication
Cultural Anthropology
Ghana
Emergency Medicine
Diagnostic Imaging
Critical Care
Language
Anesthesia
Learning
Surveys and Questionnaires

Cite this

Brazil, Victoria ; Purdy, Eve ; Alexander, Charlotte ; Matulich, Jack. / Improving the relational aspects of trauma care through translational simulation. In: Advances in Simulation (London, England). 2019 ; Vol. 4.
@article{2d882a7b3ed54ea9bc3fb8edcf2cef62,
title = "Improving the relational aspects of trauma care through translational simulation",
abstract = "Background: Major trauma care is complex and requires individuals and teams to perform together in time critical, high-stakes situations. Scenario-based simulation is well established as a strategy for trauma teamwork improvement, but its role in the relational and cultural aspects of trauma care is less well understood. Relational coordination theory offers a framework through which we aimed to understand the impact of an established trauma simulation programme.Methods: We studied simulation activities using a narrative survey of trauma providers from anaesthesia, emergency medicine, medical imaging, surgery, trauma service, intensive care, and pre-hospital providers at Gold Coast University Hospital, in conjunction with data from an ethnography. Data analysis was performed using a recursive approach-a simultaneous deductive approach using the relational coordination framework and an inductive analysis.Results: Ninety-five of 480 (19.8{\%}) staff completed free-text survey questions on simulation. Deductive analysis of data from these narrative survey results using the RC framework domains identified examples of shared goals, shared knowledge, communication and mutual respect. Two major themes from the inductive analysis-{"}Behaviour, process and system change{"} and {"}Culture and relationships{"}-aligned closely with findings from the RC analysis, with additional themes of {"}Personal and team learning{"} and the {"}Impact of the simulation experience{"} identified.Conclusions: Our findings suggest that an established trauma simulation programme can have a profound impact on the relational aspects of care and the development of a collaborative culture, with perceived tangible impacts on teamwork behaviours and institutional systems and processes. The RC framework-shared knowledge, shared goals and mutual respect in the context of communication that is timely, accurate, frequent and problem-solving based-can provide a common language for simulation educators to design and debrief simulation exercises that aim to have a translational impact.",
author = "Victoria Brazil and Eve Purdy and Charlotte Alexander and Jack Matulich",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "21",
doi = "10.1186/s41077-019-0100-2",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
journal = "Advances in Simulation (London, England)",
issn = "2059-0628",
publisher = "BioMed Central Ltd.",

}

Improving the relational aspects of trauma care through translational simulation. / Brazil, Victoria; Purdy, Eve; Alexander, Charlotte; Matulich, Jack.

In: Advances in Simulation (London, England), Vol. 4, 10, 21.05.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Improving the relational aspects of trauma care through translational simulation

AU - Brazil, Victoria

AU - Purdy, Eve

AU - Alexander, Charlotte

AU - Matulich, Jack

PY - 2019/5/21

Y1 - 2019/5/21

N2 - Background: Major trauma care is complex and requires individuals and teams to perform together in time critical, high-stakes situations. Scenario-based simulation is well established as a strategy for trauma teamwork improvement, but its role in the relational and cultural aspects of trauma care is less well understood. Relational coordination theory offers a framework through which we aimed to understand the impact of an established trauma simulation programme.Methods: We studied simulation activities using a narrative survey of trauma providers from anaesthesia, emergency medicine, medical imaging, surgery, trauma service, intensive care, and pre-hospital providers at Gold Coast University Hospital, in conjunction with data from an ethnography. Data analysis was performed using a recursive approach-a simultaneous deductive approach using the relational coordination framework and an inductive analysis.Results: Ninety-five of 480 (19.8%) staff completed free-text survey questions on simulation. Deductive analysis of data from these narrative survey results using the RC framework domains identified examples of shared goals, shared knowledge, communication and mutual respect. Two major themes from the inductive analysis-"Behaviour, process and system change" and "Culture and relationships"-aligned closely with findings from the RC analysis, with additional themes of "Personal and team learning" and the "Impact of the simulation experience" identified.Conclusions: Our findings suggest that an established trauma simulation programme can have a profound impact on the relational aspects of care and the development of a collaborative culture, with perceived tangible impacts on teamwork behaviours and institutional systems and processes. The RC framework-shared knowledge, shared goals and mutual respect in the context of communication that is timely, accurate, frequent and problem-solving based-can provide a common language for simulation educators to design and debrief simulation exercises that aim to have a translational impact.

AB - Background: Major trauma care is complex and requires individuals and teams to perform together in time critical, high-stakes situations. Scenario-based simulation is well established as a strategy for trauma teamwork improvement, but its role in the relational and cultural aspects of trauma care is less well understood. Relational coordination theory offers a framework through which we aimed to understand the impact of an established trauma simulation programme.Methods: We studied simulation activities using a narrative survey of trauma providers from anaesthesia, emergency medicine, medical imaging, surgery, trauma service, intensive care, and pre-hospital providers at Gold Coast University Hospital, in conjunction with data from an ethnography. Data analysis was performed using a recursive approach-a simultaneous deductive approach using the relational coordination framework and an inductive analysis.Results: Ninety-five of 480 (19.8%) staff completed free-text survey questions on simulation. Deductive analysis of data from these narrative survey results using the RC framework domains identified examples of shared goals, shared knowledge, communication and mutual respect. Two major themes from the inductive analysis-"Behaviour, process and system change" and "Culture and relationships"-aligned closely with findings from the RC analysis, with additional themes of "Personal and team learning" and the "Impact of the simulation experience" identified.Conclusions: Our findings suggest that an established trauma simulation programme can have a profound impact on the relational aspects of care and the development of a collaborative culture, with perceived tangible impacts on teamwork behaviours and institutional systems and processes. The RC framework-shared knowledge, shared goals and mutual respect in the context of communication that is timely, accurate, frequent and problem-solving based-can provide a common language for simulation educators to design and debrief simulation exercises that aim to have a translational impact.

U2 - 10.1186/s41077-019-0100-2

DO - 10.1186/s41077-019-0100-2

M3 - Article

VL - 4

JO - Advances in Simulation (London, England)

JF - Advances in Simulation (London, England)

SN - 2059-0628

M1 - 10

ER -