Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change

Susan Brandis, Ron Fisher, Ruth McPhail, John Rice, Kathy Eljiz, Anneke Fitzgerald, Rod Gapp, Andrea Marshall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective This study examines the relationships between job satisfaction and organisational justice during a time of transformational change. Methods Data collection occurred immediately before a major regional hospital's move to a greenfield site. Existing measures of job satisfaction and organisational justice were used. Data were analysed (n=316) using descriptive, correlation and regression methods together with interactions between predictor variables. Results Correlation coefficients for satisfaction and organisational justice variables were high and significant at the P<0.001 level. Results of a robust regression model (adjusted R(2)=0.568) showed all three components of organisational justice contributed significantly to employee job satisfaction. Interactions between the predictor variables showed that job satisfaction increased as the interactions between the predictor variables increased. Conclusions The finding that even at a time of transformational change staff perceptions of fair treatment will in the main result in high job satisfaction extends the literature in this area. In addition, it was found that increasing rewards for staff who perceive low levels of organisational justice does not increase satisfaction as much as for staff who perceive high levels of fairness. If people feel negative about their role, but feel they are well paid, they probably still have negative feelings overall. What is known about the topic? Despite much research highlighting the importance of job satisfaction and organisational justice in healthcare, no research has examined the influence of transformational change, such as a healthcare organisational relocation, on these factors. What does this paper add? The research adds to academic literature relating to job satisfaction and organisational justice. It highlights the importance of organisational justice in influencing the job satisfaction of staff. What are the implications for practitioners? Financial rewards do not necessarily motivate staff but low rewards do demotivate. Shortages of health professionals are often linked to a lack of job satisfaction, and recruitment and retention strategies are often based on salary.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)292-298
Number of pages7
JournalAustralian Health Review
Volume40
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2016
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Job Satisfaction
Social Justice
Reward
Health Services Research
Salaries and Fringe Benefits
Research
Emotions
Delivery of Health Care
Health

Cite this

Brandis, Susan ; Fisher, Ron ; McPhail, Ruth ; Rice, John ; Eljiz, Kathy ; Fitzgerald, Anneke ; Gapp, Rod ; Marshall, Andrea. / Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change. In: Australian Health Review. 2016 ; Vol. 40, No. 3. pp. 292-298.
@article{5b0a97c22b4644a1ae1a7edf7393be2e,
title = "Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change",
abstract = "Objective This study examines the relationships between job satisfaction and organisational justice during a time of transformational change. Methods Data collection occurred immediately before a major regional hospital's move to a greenfield site. Existing measures of job satisfaction and organisational justice were used. Data were analysed (n=316) using descriptive, correlation and regression methods together with interactions between predictor variables. Results Correlation coefficients for satisfaction and organisational justice variables were high and significant at the P<0.001 level. Results of a robust regression model (adjusted R(2)=0.568) showed all three components of organisational justice contributed significantly to employee job satisfaction. Interactions between the predictor variables showed that job satisfaction increased as the interactions between the predictor variables increased. Conclusions The finding that even at a time of transformational change staff perceptions of fair treatment will in the main result in high job satisfaction extends the literature in this area. In addition, it was found that increasing rewards for staff who perceive low levels of organisational justice does not increase satisfaction as much as for staff who perceive high levels of fairness. If people feel negative about their role, but feel they are well paid, they probably still have negative feelings overall. What is known about the topic? Despite much research highlighting the importance of job satisfaction and organisational justice in healthcare, no research has examined the influence of transformational change, such as a healthcare organisational relocation, on these factors. What does this paper add? The research adds to academic literature relating to job satisfaction and organisational justice. It highlights the importance of organisational justice in influencing the job satisfaction of staff. What are the implications for practitioners? Financial rewards do not necessarily motivate staff but low rewards do demotivate. Shortages of health professionals are often linked to a lack of job satisfaction, and recruitment and retention strategies are often based on salary.",
author = "Susan Brandis and Ron Fisher and Ruth McPhail and John Rice and Kathy Eljiz and Anneke Fitzgerald and Rod Gapp and Andrea Marshall",
year = "2016",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1071/AH15031",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "292--298",
journal = "Australia and New Zealand Health Policy",
issn = "1743-8462",
publisher = "CSIRO Publishing",
number = "3",

}

Brandis, S, Fisher, R, McPhail, R, Rice, J, Eljiz, K, Fitzgerald, A, Gapp, R & Marshall, A 2016, 'Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change' Australian Health Review, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 292-298. https://doi.org/10.1071/AH15031

Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change. / Brandis, Susan; Fisher, Ron; McPhail, Ruth; Rice, John; Eljiz, Kathy; Fitzgerald, Anneke; Gapp, Rod; Marshall, Andrea.

In: Australian Health Review, Vol. 40, No. 3, 06.2016, p. 292-298.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Hospital employees' perceptions of fairness and job satisfaction at a time of transformational change

AU - Brandis, Susan

AU - Fisher, Ron

AU - McPhail, Ruth

AU - Rice, John

AU - Eljiz, Kathy

AU - Fitzgerald, Anneke

AU - Gapp, Rod

AU - Marshall, Andrea

PY - 2016/6

Y1 - 2016/6

N2 - Objective This study examines the relationships between job satisfaction and organisational justice during a time of transformational change. Methods Data collection occurred immediately before a major regional hospital's move to a greenfield site. Existing measures of job satisfaction and organisational justice were used. Data were analysed (n=316) using descriptive, correlation and regression methods together with interactions between predictor variables. Results Correlation coefficients for satisfaction and organisational justice variables were high and significant at the P<0.001 level. Results of a robust regression model (adjusted R(2)=0.568) showed all three components of organisational justice contributed significantly to employee job satisfaction. Interactions between the predictor variables showed that job satisfaction increased as the interactions between the predictor variables increased. Conclusions The finding that even at a time of transformational change staff perceptions of fair treatment will in the main result in high job satisfaction extends the literature in this area. In addition, it was found that increasing rewards for staff who perceive low levels of organisational justice does not increase satisfaction as much as for staff who perceive high levels of fairness. If people feel negative about their role, but feel they are well paid, they probably still have negative feelings overall. What is known about the topic? Despite much research highlighting the importance of job satisfaction and organisational justice in healthcare, no research has examined the influence of transformational change, such as a healthcare organisational relocation, on these factors. What does this paper add? The research adds to academic literature relating to job satisfaction and organisational justice. It highlights the importance of organisational justice in influencing the job satisfaction of staff. What are the implications for practitioners? Financial rewards do not necessarily motivate staff but low rewards do demotivate. Shortages of health professionals are often linked to a lack of job satisfaction, and recruitment and retention strategies are often based on salary.

AB - Objective This study examines the relationships between job satisfaction and organisational justice during a time of transformational change. Methods Data collection occurred immediately before a major regional hospital's move to a greenfield site. Existing measures of job satisfaction and organisational justice were used. Data were analysed (n=316) using descriptive, correlation and regression methods together with interactions between predictor variables. Results Correlation coefficients for satisfaction and organisational justice variables were high and significant at the P<0.001 level. Results of a robust regression model (adjusted R(2)=0.568) showed all three components of organisational justice contributed significantly to employee job satisfaction. Interactions between the predictor variables showed that job satisfaction increased as the interactions between the predictor variables increased. Conclusions The finding that even at a time of transformational change staff perceptions of fair treatment will in the main result in high job satisfaction extends the literature in this area. In addition, it was found that increasing rewards for staff who perceive low levels of organisational justice does not increase satisfaction as much as for staff who perceive high levels of fairness. If people feel negative about their role, but feel they are well paid, they probably still have negative feelings overall. What is known about the topic? Despite much research highlighting the importance of job satisfaction and organisational justice in healthcare, no research has examined the influence of transformational change, such as a healthcare organisational relocation, on these factors. What does this paper add? The research adds to academic literature relating to job satisfaction and organisational justice. It highlights the importance of organisational justice in influencing the job satisfaction of staff. What are the implications for practitioners? Financial rewards do not necessarily motivate staff but low rewards do demotivate. Shortages of health professionals are often linked to a lack of job satisfaction, and recruitment and retention strategies are often based on salary.

U2 - 10.1071/AH15031

DO - 10.1071/AH15031

M3 - Article

VL - 40

SP - 292

EP - 298

JO - Australia and New Zealand Health Policy

JF - Australia and New Zealand Health Policy

SN - 1743-8462

IS - 3

ER -