Factors associated with the number of lesions excised for each skin cancer: A study of primary care physicians in Queensland, Australia

Peter D. Baade, Philippa H. Youl, Monika Janda, David C. Whiteman, Christopher B. Del Mar, Joanne F. Aitken

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: To assess physician, patient, and skin lesion characteristics that affect the number of benign skin lesions excised by primary care physicians for each skin cancer. Design: Prospective study collecting clinical, patient, and histopathologic details of excisions or biopsies of skin lesions by random samples of primary care physicians. Setting: Southeast Queensland involving traditional family medicine physicians (n=104; response rate,53.9%) and family medicine physicians working in 27 primary care skin cancer clinics (n=50; response rate,75.0%). Participants: Of 28 755 skin examinations recorded during the study, 11 403 skin lesions were excised or biopsied; 97.5% of the excised lesions had clinical and histologic diagnoses recorded. Main Outcome Measures: Number of lesions needed to excise or biopsy (NNE) for 1 melanoma (pigmented lesions only) and NNE for 1 nonmelanoma skin cancer (nonpigmented lesions only). Results: The NNE for nonpigmented lesions (n=8139) was 1.5 (95% confidence interval, 1.4-1.6) and for pigmented lesions (n=2977) was 19.6 (16.2-22.9). The NNE estimates were up to 8 times lower if the physician thought the lesion was likely to be malignant and up to 2.5 times higher if there was strong patient pressure to excise. The NNE estimates varied by other physician-, patient-, and lesion-related variables. Conclusions: Clinical impressions of excised skin lesions were strongly associated with NNE estimates. By focusing on pigmented skin lesions and by addressing the physician- and patient-specific factors identified, the effectiveness of future training for primary care physicians in the clinical management of skin cancer could be improved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1468-1476
Number of pages9
JournalArchives of Dermatology
Volume144
Issue number11
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2008

Fingerprint

Queensland
Primary Care Physicians
Skin Neoplasms
Skin
Physicians
Family Physicians
Biopsy
Traditional Medicine
Melanoma
Primary Health Care
Medicine
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Prospective Studies
Confidence Intervals
Pressure

Cite this

Baade, Peter D. ; Youl, Philippa H. ; Janda, Monika ; Whiteman, David C. ; Del Mar, Christopher B. ; Aitken, Joanne F. / Factors associated with the number of lesions excised for each skin cancer : A study of primary care physicians in Queensland, Australia. In: Archives of Dermatology. 2008 ; Vol. 144, No. 11. pp. 1468-1476.
@article{c795ecea0ebf451e9af28cd93f4f3585,
title = "Factors associated with the number of lesions excised for each skin cancer: A study of primary care physicians in Queensland, Australia",
abstract = "Objective: To assess physician, patient, and skin lesion characteristics that affect the number of benign skin lesions excised by primary care physicians for each skin cancer. Design: Prospective study collecting clinical, patient, and histopathologic details of excisions or biopsies of skin lesions by random samples of primary care physicians. Setting: Southeast Queensland involving traditional family medicine physicians (n=104; response rate,53.9{\%}) and family medicine physicians working in 27 primary care skin cancer clinics (n=50; response rate,75.0{\%}). Participants: Of 28 755 skin examinations recorded during the study, 11 403 skin lesions were excised or biopsied; 97.5{\%} of the excised lesions had clinical and histologic diagnoses recorded. Main Outcome Measures: Number of lesions needed to excise or biopsy (NNE) for 1 melanoma (pigmented lesions only) and NNE for 1 nonmelanoma skin cancer (nonpigmented lesions only). Results: The NNE for nonpigmented lesions (n=8139) was 1.5 (95{\%} confidence interval, 1.4-1.6) and for pigmented lesions (n=2977) was 19.6 (16.2-22.9). The NNE estimates were up to 8 times lower if the physician thought the lesion was likely to be malignant and up to 2.5 times higher if there was strong patient pressure to excise. The NNE estimates varied by other physician-, patient-, and lesion-related variables. Conclusions: Clinical impressions of excised skin lesions were strongly associated with NNE estimates. By focusing on pigmented skin lesions and by addressing the physician- and patient-specific factors identified, the effectiveness of future training for primary care physicians in the clinical management of skin cancer could be improved.",
author = "Baade, {Peter D.} and Youl, {Philippa H.} and Monika Janda and Whiteman, {David C.} and {Del Mar}, {Christopher B.} and Aitken, {Joanne F.}",
year = "2008",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1001/archderm.144.11.1468",
language = "English",
volume = "144",
pages = "1468--1476",
journal = "JAMA Dermatology",
issn = "0003-987X",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "11",

}

Factors associated with the number of lesions excised for each skin cancer : A study of primary care physicians in Queensland, Australia. / Baade, Peter D.; Youl, Philippa H.; Janda, Monika; Whiteman, David C.; Del Mar, Christopher B.; Aitken, Joanne F.

In: Archives of Dermatology, Vol. 144, No. 11, 11.2008, p. 1468-1476.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Factors associated with the number of lesions excised for each skin cancer

T2 - A study of primary care physicians in Queensland, Australia

AU - Baade, Peter D.

AU - Youl, Philippa H.

AU - Janda, Monika

AU - Whiteman, David C.

AU - Del Mar, Christopher B.

AU - Aitken, Joanne F.

PY - 2008/11

Y1 - 2008/11

N2 - Objective: To assess physician, patient, and skin lesion characteristics that affect the number of benign skin lesions excised by primary care physicians for each skin cancer. Design: Prospective study collecting clinical, patient, and histopathologic details of excisions or biopsies of skin lesions by random samples of primary care physicians. Setting: Southeast Queensland involving traditional family medicine physicians (n=104; response rate,53.9%) and family medicine physicians working in 27 primary care skin cancer clinics (n=50; response rate,75.0%). Participants: Of 28 755 skin examinations recorded during the study, 11 403 skin lesions were excised or biopsied; 97.5% of the excised lesions had clinical and histologic diagnoses recorded. Main Outcome Measures: Number of lesions needed to excise or biopsy (NNE) for 1 melanoma (pigmented lesions only) and NNE for 1 nonmelanoma skin cancer (nonpigmented lesions only). Results: The NNE for nonpigmented lesions (n=8139) was 1.5 (95% confidence interval, 1.4-1.6) and for pigmented lesions (n=2977) was 19.6 (16.2-22.9). The NNE estimates were up to 8 times lower if the physician thought the lesion was likely to be malignant and up to 2.5 times higher if there was strong patient pressure to excise. The NNE estimates varied by other physician-, patient-, and lesion-related variables. Conclusions: Clinical impressions of excised skin lesions were strongly associated with NNE estimates. By focusing on pigmented skin lesions and by addressing the physician- and patient-specific factors identified, the effectiveness of future training for primary care physicians in the clinical management of skin cancer could be improved.

AB - Objective: To assess physician, patient, and skin lesion characteristics that affect the number of benign skin lesions excised by primary care physicians for each skin cancer. Design: Prospective study collecting clinical, patient, and histopathologic details of excisions or biopsies of skin lesions by random samples of primary care physicians. Setting: Southeast Queensland involving traditional family medicine physicians (n=104; response rate,53.9%) and family medicine physicians working in 27 primary care skin cancer clinics (n=50; response rate,75.0%). Participants: Of 28 755 skin examinations recorded during the study, 11 403 skin lesions were excised or biopsied; 97.5% of the excised lesions had clinical and histologic diagnoses recorded. Main Outcome Measures: Number of lesions needed to excise or biopsy (NNE) for 1 melanoma (pigmented lesions only) and NNE for 1 nonmelanoma skin cancer (nonpigmented lesions only). Results: The NNE for nonpigmented lesions (n=8139) was 1.5 (95% confidence interval, 1.4-1.6) and for pigmented lesions (n=2977) was 19.6 (16.2-22.9). The NNE estimates were up to 8 times lower if the physician thought the lesion was likely to be malignant and up to 2.5 times higher if there was strong patient pressure to excise. The NNE estimates varied by other physician-, patient-, and lesion-related variables. Conclusions: Clinical impressions of excised skin lesions were strongly associated with NNE estimates. By focusing on pigmented skin lesions and by addressing the physician- and patient-specific factors identified, the effectiveness of future training for primary care physicians in the clinical management of skin cancer could be improved.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=56549115591&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1001/archderm.144.11.1468

DO - 10.1001/archderm.144.11.1468

M3 - Article

VL - 144

SP - 1468

EP - 1476

JO - JAMA Dermatology

JF - JAMA Dermatology

SN - 0003-987X

IS - 11

ER -