Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test

Ismail Waheed, Raymond McNamara, Keith Duncan

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This study identifies what accountants and auditors perceive as the main attribute that gives a company the ability to have dominant control over other companies for the purpose of consolidated financial reporting. US GAAP regulations have stated dominant control is possible through owning majority of shares or voting rights. Other international standards, such as IFRS, shows a broader definitions of control exist in addition to majority of share ownership. The main attributes of control tested to identify control judgments are the total level of ownership, the level of direct and indirect ownership, the dispersion of ownership and the representation level in the Board of Directors. Conjoint analysis is used for this purpose. Participants evaluated different case scenarios that consists of attributes of control constructed as an orthogonal array. Participants are asked if, under each case, a company can be controlled or not and how confident they are with their decision. The data collected are tested at an individual (each participant separately) and aggregate level (all the participants as a whole) to disaggregate participant’s evaluations. The results show the majority of ownership and the level of board representation are the attributes significantly contributing to dominant-control judgments. Level of direct and indirect ownership and dispersion of ownership no have significant influence on ability to govern entities. Furthermore, a combination
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages34
Publication statusPublished - May 2019
EventThe 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association - Aliathon Holiday Village Hotel, Paphos, Cyprus
Duration: 29 May 201931 May 2019
Conference number: 42nd
http://www.eaa-online.org/r/?iId=FFMIHL
http://www.eaacongress.org/r/home (EAA 2019)
http://www.eaacongress.org/userfiles/EAA%202019%20Programme%20Book%20-%2024.05.19.pdf (Programme Book)

Conference

ConferenceThe 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association
Abbreviated titleEAA
CountryCyprus
CityPaphos
Period29/05/1931/05/19
OtherThe Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association is a major event that takes place in a different country during springtime each year. The EAA Annual Congress offers a unique opportunity for presenting research and finding out what colleagues in the fields of management and accounting are doing. Every year between 1.200 and 1.500 delegates attend this popular event and around 800 and 1.000 papers are presented in parallel sessions and research fora.
Internet address

Fingerprint

Financial reporting
Empirical test
Ownership
Share ownership
International Financial Reporting Standards
Accountants
Conjoint analysis
Scenarios
Board of directors
Voting rights
International standards
Evaluation
Orthogonal array
Auditors

Cite this

Waheed, I., McNamara, R., & Duncan, K. (2019). Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test. Paper presented at The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , Paphos, Cyprus.
Waheed, Ismail ; McNamara, Raymond ; Duncan, Keith. / Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test. Paper presented at The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , Paphos, Cyprus.34 p.
@conference{cfd21c91c0714d39abe4473724e5a074,
title = "Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test",
abstract = "This study identifies what accountants and auditors perceive as the main attribute that gives a company the ability to have dominant control over other companies for the purpose of consolidated financial reporting. US GAAP regulations have stated dominant control is possible through owning majority of shares or voting rights. Other international standards, such as IFRS, shows a broader definitions of control exist in addition to majority of share ownership. The main attributes of control tested to identify control judgments are the total level of ownership, the level of direct and indirect ownership, the dispersion of ownership and the representation level in the Board of Directors. Conjoint analysis is used for this purpose. Participants evaluated different case scenarios that consists of attributes of control constructed as an orthogonal array. Participants are asked if, under each case, a company can be controlled or not and how confident they are with their decision. The data collected are tested at an individual (each participant separately) and aggregate level (all the participants as a whole) to disaggregate participant’s evaluations. The results show the majority of ownership and the level of board representation are the attributes significantly contributing to dominant-control judgments. Level of direct and indirect ownership and dispersion of ownership no have significant influence on ability to govern entities. Furthermore, a combination",
author = "Ismail Waheed and Raymond McNamara and Keith Duncan",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
language = "English",
note = "The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , EAA ; Conference date: 29-05-2019 Through 31-05-2019",
url = "http://www.eaa-online.org/r/?iId=FFMIHL, http://www.eaacongress.org/r/home, http://www.eaacongress.org/userfiles/EAA{\%}202019{\%}20Programme{\%}20Book{\%}20-{\%}2024.05.19.pdf",

}

Waheed, I, McNamara, R & Duncan, K 2019, 'Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test' Paper presented at The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , Paphos, Cyprus, 29/05/19 - 31/05/19, .

Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test. / Waheed, Ismail; McNamara, Raymond; Duncan, Keith.

2019. Paper presented at The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , Paphos, Cyprus.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperResearchpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test

AU - Waheed, Ismail

AU - McNamara, Raymond

AU - Duncan, Keith

PY - 2019/5

Y1 - 2019/5

N2 - This study identifies what accountants and auditors perceive as the main attribute that gives a company the ability to have dominant control over other companies for the purpose of consolidated financial reporting. US GAAP regulations have stated dominant control is possible through owning majority of shares or voting rights. Other international standards, such as IFRS, shows a broader definitions of control exist in addition to majority of share ownership. The main attributes of control tested to identify control judgments are the total level of ownership, the level of direct and indirect ownership, the dispersion of ownership and the representation level in the Board of Directors. Conjoint analysis is used for this purpose. Participants evaluated different case scenarios that consists of attributes of control constructed as an orthogonal array. Participants are asked if, under each case, a company can be controlled or not and how confident they are with their decision. The data collected are tested at an individual (each participant separately) and aggregate level (all the participants as a whole) to disaggregate participant’s evaluations. The results show the majority of ownership and the level of board representation are the attributes significantly contributing to dominant-control judgments. Level of direct and indirect ownership and dispersion of ownership no have significant influence on ability to govern entities. Furthermore, a combination

AB - This study identifies what accountants and auditors perceive as the main attribute that gives a company the ability to have dominant control over other companies for the purpose of consolidated financial reporting. US GAAP regulations have stated dominant control is possible through owning majority of shares or voting rights. Other international standards, such as IFRS, shows a broader definitions of control exist in addition to majority of share ownership. The main attributes of control tested to identify control judgments are the total level of ownership, the level of direct and indirect ownership, the dispersion of ownership and the representation level in the Board of Directors. Conjoint analysis is used for this purpose. Participants evaluated different case scenarios that consists of attributes of control constructed as an orthogonal array. Participants are asked if, under each case, a company can be controlled or not and how confident they are with their decision. The data collected are tested at an individual (each participant separately) and aggregate level (all the participants as a whole) to disaggregate participant’s evaluations. The results show the majority of ownership and the level of board representation are the attributes significantly contributing to dominant-control judgments. Level of direct and indirect ownership and dispersion of ownership no have significant influence on ability to govern entities. Furthermore, a combination

M3 - Paper

ER -

Waheed I, McNamara R, Duncan K. Control in financial reporting: Theory and an empirical test. 2019. Paper presented at The 42nd Annual Congress of the European Accounting Association , Paphos, Cyprus.