Complementary and alternative medicine and consumer law

Michael Weir, Jon L. Wardle, Brenda Marshall, Eloise Archer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The application of consumer Law has become significant in the health sector including the provision of complementary and alternative medicine. Many legal authorities in this area deal with extreme examples of breaches of consumer law which provides a problematic image for the evidence base for this form of health care especially when high quality scientific is sought in regard to representations made. The article discusses the fact that in some contexts traditional use evidence is applied in regard to the determination of appropriate indications of use for the registration and listing of complementary and alternative medicine but this does not appear to be applied in consumer law decisions. The capacity to provide high quality scientific evidence is limited for many form of complementary and alternative medicine based upon their historical background and approach to healing. Based upon an analysis of the value obtained from scientific evidence for complementary and alternative medicine this article argues for a broader use of traditional evidence and other forms of evidence to support compliance with consumer legislation in a context of where public safety is preserved.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)85-110
Number of pages26
JournalCompetition and Consumer Law Journal
Volume21
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

alternative medicine
Law
evidence
indication
legislation
health care
health

Cite this

@article{331121e85d8e431081fe13191c681bfb,
title = "Complementary and alternative medicine and consumer law",
abstract = "The application of consumer Law has become significant in the health sector including the provision of complementary and alternative medicine. Many legal authorities in this area deal with extreme examples of breaches of consumer law which provides a problematic image for the evidence base for this form of health care especially when high quality scientific is sought in regard to representations made. The article discusses the fact that in some contexts traditional use evidence is applied in regard to the determination of appropriate indications of use for the registration and listing of complementary and alternative medicine but this does not appear to be applied in consumer law decisions. The capacity to provide high quality scientific evidence is limited for many form of complementary and alternative medicine based upon their historical background and approach to healing. Based upon an analysis of the value obtained from scientific evidence for complementary and alternative medicine this article argues for a broader use of traditional evidence and other forms of evidence to support compliance with consumer legislation in a context of where public safety is preserved.",
author = "Michael Weir and Wardle, {Jon L.} and Brenda Marshall and Eloise Archer",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "85--110",
journal = "Competition and Consumer Law",
issn = "1039-5598",
publisher = "LexisNexis Butterworths",
number = "1",

}

Complementary and alternative medicine and consumer law. / Weir, Michael; Wardle, Jon L.; Marshall, Brenda; Archer, Eloise.

In: Competition and Consumer Law Journal, Vol. 21, No. 1, 2013, p. 85-110.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Complementary and alternative medicine and consumer law

AU - Weir, Michael

AU - Wardle, Jon L.

AU - Marshall, Brenda

AU - Archer, Eloise

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - The application of consumer Law has become significant in the health sector including the provision of complementary and alternative medicine. Many legal authorities in this area deal with extreme examples of breaches of consumer law which provides a problematic image for the evidence base for this form of health care especially when high quality scientific is sought in regard to representations made. The article discusses the fact that in some contexts traditional use evidence is applied in regard to the determination of appropriate indications of use for the registration and listing of complementary and alternative medicine but this does not appear to be applied in consumer law decisions. The capacity to provide high quality scientific evidence is limited for many form of complementary and alternative medicine based upon their historical background and approach to healing. Based upon an analysis of the value obtained from scientific evidence for complementary and alternative medicine this article argues for a broader use of traditional evidence and other forms of evidence to support compliance with consumer legislation in a context of where public safety is preserved.

AB - The application of consumer Law has become significant in the health sector including the provision of complementary and alternative medicine. Many legal authorities in this area deal with extreme examples of breaches of consumer law which provides a problematic image for the evidence base for this form of health care especially when high quality scientific is sought in regard to representations made. The article discusses the fact that in some contexts traditional use evidence is applied in regard to the determination of appropriate indications of use for the registration and listing of complementary and alternative medicine but this does not appear to be applied in consumer law decisions. The capacity to provide high quality scientific evidence is limited for many form of complementary and alternative medicine based upon their historical background and approach to healing. Based upon an analysis of the value obtained from scientific evidence for complementary and alternative medicine this article argues for a broader use of traditional evidence and other forms of evidence to support compliance with consumer legislation in a context of where public safety is preserved.

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 85

EP - 110

JO - Competition and Consumer Law

JF - Competition and Consumer Law

SN - 1039-5598

IS - 1

ER -