A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7

Julie-Anne Kelso

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

In the Song of Songs, the beating of the woman by the watchmen in 5:7 is generally understood to be either part of a dream or waking fantasy by the woman. Briefly, having risen to open the door to her beloved, she is stunned to find that he has left. She goes out searching for him, but the watchmen instead find, beat, bruise and strip her (Song 5:2-7). This is a problematic moment in the text, especially for those who wish the Song to be understood as an egalitarian model of love between the sexes. However, according to Virginia Burrus and Stephen Moore's (2003) recent work on the Song, developed especially in light of Roland Boer's own pornographic x-egesis, the "beating" scene might just subvert the oppressive reduction of woman to passive sexual partner, even victim, expressing instead woman's desire for masochistic enjoyment.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe one who reads may run
Subtitle of host publicationEssays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad
EditorsR. Boer, M. Carden, J. Kelso
Place of PublicationNew York
PublisherT&T Clark (International)
Pages160-175
Number of pages16
ISBN (Print)9780567602176
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

Song of Songs
Song
Wishes
Beloved
Boer
Sexual
Fantasy
Enjoyment

Cite this

Kelso, J-A. (2012). A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7. In R. Boer, M. Carden, & J. Kelso (Eds.), The one who reads may run: Essays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad (pp. 160-175). New York: T&T Clark (International).
Kelso, Julie-Anne. / A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7. The one who reads may run: Essays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad. editor / R. Boer ; M. Carden ; J. Kelso. New York : T&T Clark (International), 2012. pp. 160-175
@inbook{bc57f00caebc4fecbfb3b05df258fc4c,
title = "A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7",
abstract = "In the Song of Songs, the beating of the woman by the watchmen in 5:7 is generally understood to be either part of a dream or waking fantasy by the woman. Briefly, having risen to open the door to her beloved, she is stunned to find that he has left. She goes out searching for him, but the watchmen instead find, beat, bruise and strip her (Song 5:2-7). This is a problematic moment in the text, especially for those who wish the Song to be understood as an egalitarian model of love between the sexes. However, according to Virginia Burrus and Stephen Moore's (2003) recent work on the Song, developed especially in light of Roland Boer's own pornographic x-egesis, the {"}beating{"} scene might just subvert the oppressive reduction of woman to passive sexual partner, even victim, expressing instead woman's desire for masochistic enjoyment.",
author = "Julie-Anne Kelso",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780567602176",
pages = "160--175",
editor = "R. Boer and M. Carden and J. Kelso",
booktitle = "The one who reads may run",
publisher = "T&T Clark (International)",

}

Kelso, J-A 2012, A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7. in R Boer, M Carden & J Kelso (eds), The one who reads may run: Essays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad. T&T Clark (International), New York, pp. 160-175.

A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7. / Kelso, Julie-Anne.

The one who reads may run: Essays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad. ed. / R. Boer; M. Carden; J. Kelso. New York : T&T Clark (International), 2012. p. 160-175.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7

AU - Kelso, Julie-Anne

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - In the Song of Songs, the beating of the woman by the watchmen in 5:7 is generally understood to be either part of a dream or waking fantasy by the woman. Briefly, having risen to open the door to her beloved, she is stunned to find that he has left. She goes out searching for him, but the watchmen instead find, beat, bruise and strip her (Song 5:2-7). This is a problematic moment in the text, especially for those who wish the Song to be understood as an egalitarian model of love between the sexes. However, according to Virginia Burrus and Stephen Moore's (2003) recent work on the Song, developed especially in light of Roland Boer's own pornographic x-egesis, the "beating" scene might just subvert the oppressive reduction of woman to passive sexual partner, even victim, expressing instead woman's desire for masochistic enjoyment.

AB - In the Song of Songs, the beating of the woman by the watchmen in 5:7 is generally understood to be either part of a dream or waking fantasy by the woman. Briefly, having risen to open the door to her beloved, she is stunned to find that he has left. She goes out searching for him, but the watchmen instead find, beat, bruise and strip her (Song 5:2-7). This is a problematic moment in the text, especially for those who wish the Song to be understood as an egalitarian model of love between the sexes. However, according to Virginia Burrus and Stephen Moore's (2003) recent work on the Song, developed especially in light of Roland Boer's own pornographic x-egesis, the "beating" scene might just subvert the oppressive reduction of woman to passive sexual partner, even victim, expressing instead woman's desire for masochistic enjoyment.

UR - http://www.bloomsbury.com/au/the-one-who-reads-may-run-9780567602176/

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780567602176

SP - 160

EP - 175

BT - The one who reads may run

A2 - Boer, R.

A2 - Carden, M.

A2 - Kelso, J.

PB - T&T Clark (International)

CY - New York

ER -

Kelso J-A. A woman is being beaten and maybe she likes it? Approaching Song of Songs 5:2-7. In Boer R, Carden M, Kelso J, editors, The one who reads may run: Essays in honour of Edgar W. Conrad. New York: T&T Clark (International). 2012. p. 160-175