A new ecosystem for evidence synthesis

Shinichi Nakagawa, Adam G Dunn, Malgorzata Lagisz, Alexandra Bannach-Brown, Eliza M Grames, Alfredo Sánchez-Tójar, Rose E O'Dea, Daniel W A Noble, Martin J Westgate, Pieter A Arnold, Stuart Barrow, Eve Cooper, Yong Zhi Foo, Sonya R Geange, Emily Hennessy, Witness Mapanga, Kerrie Mengersen, Claudia Munera, Matthew J Page, Vivian WelchEvidence Synthesis Hackathon 2019 Participants, Neal R Haddaway

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate/opinionResearchpeer-review

36 Citations (Scopus)
393 Downloads (Pure)


Synthesizing evidence is an essential part of scientifc progress, but it is often done in a slow and uncoordinated manner, sometimes producing misleading conclusions. Here, we propose the idea of an ‘open synthesis community’ to resolve this pressing issue
In the acclaimed BBC documentary Life of Birds (1998), David Attenborough
narrated male house sparrows displaying a black patch of feathers on their chest
or bib as a ‘badge of status’ to signal their fighting ability. Ten years later, a synthesis of published studies confirmed that the bigger the patch, the higher the social status. However, another ten years later an updated synthesis included unpublished studies, and questioned whether the bib signals their status at all.
This sparrow example may seem benign but consider the following example.
An early synthesis of clinical trial evidence led governments to spend billions of
US dollars stockpiling the anti-flu drug Tamiflu. It took another ten years to access the unpublished data that showed Tamiflu was probably not as effective, or as safe, as was first believed. There are an increasing number of examples of evidence weakening or disappearing over time, not only in the field of ecology and evolution, but also in other fields. This phenomenon is called a ‘decline effect’. Such a phenomenon suggests that we should reconsider the way we synthesize evidence.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)498–501
Number of pages4
JournalNature Ecology and Evolution
Early online date23 Mar 2020
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2020


Dive into the research topics of 'A new ecosystem for evidence synthesis'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this